Grimm Alexander, Vittore Debora, Schubert Victoria, Lipski Christina, Heiling Bianka, Décard Bernhard F, Axer Hubertus
Department of Neurology, Tübingen University Hospital, Tübingen, Germany.
Department of Neurology, Tübingen University Hospital, Tübingen, Germany.
Clin Neurophysiol. 2016 Jul;127(7):2618-24. doi: 10.1016/j.clinph.2016.04.009. Epub 2016 Apr 21.
To investigate the use of nerve ultrasound in the differentiation between Charcot-Marie Tooth hereditary neuropathy (CMT1) and chronic inflammatory demyelinating polyradiculoneuropathies (CIDP), multifocal motor neuropathy (MMN) and multifocal acquired demyelinating sensory and motor neuropathies (MADSAM).
Ultrasound/electrophysiology of predefined nerves was performed in CMT1a/b, immunoneuropathies, and healthy controls. Ultrasound pattern sum score (UPSS, sum of the amount of 12 predefined measurement points), homogeneity score (HS) and regional nerve enlargement index (RNEI) in ulnar, median, and tibial nerve were used for evaluation of morphology.
13 CMT1, 27 CIDP, 10 MADSAM, 12 MMN, and 23 controls were included. Significant enlargement was shown in all neuropathies compared to the controls, (p<0.001), however the amount of enlargement as evaluated by the UPSS was most prominent in CMT compared to the others (median UPSS 18 vs. 11/8.5/5 in CIDP/MADSAM/MMN, p<0.001). Homogeneous enlargement was significantly more often seen in CMT (67%, HS 6 vs. 2-3 in immune-mediated PNP, p<0.001), while in CIDP the enlargement was regional, homogeneous or inhomogeneous with equal contribution. In MMN and MADSAM regional enlargement (48%/40%) next to normal segments (∼20%) predominated (RNEI in MMN=2, in MADSAM=1 vs. 0 in the others). CSAs were inversely correlated with motor conduction velocity.
Ultrasound, quantified by UPSS, HS, and RNEI facilitates a reliable and reproducible differentiation of immunoneuropathies and hereditary neuropathies by the use of boundary values.
By the use of quantitative scores, ultrasound differentiation of demyelinating neuropathies is operationalized and ameliorated compared to CSA measurements only.
探讨神经超声在鉴别遗传性夏科-马里-图斯神经病(CMT1)与慢性炎症性脱髓鞘性多发性神经根神经病(CIDP)、多灶性运动神经病(MMN)以及多灶性获得性脱髓鞘性感觉和运动神经病(MADSAM)中的应用。
对CMT1a/b患者、免疫性神经病患者及健康对照者的预定义神经进行超声/电生理检查。使用超声模式总和评分(UPSS,12个预定义测量点的总和)、均匀性评分(HS)以及尺神经、正中神经和胫神经的区域神经增粗指数(RNEI)来评估神经形态。
纳入了13例CMT1患者、27例CIDP患者、10例MADSAM患者、12例MMN患者和23名对照者。与对照组相比,所有神经病患者均显示出明显的神经增粗(p<0.001),然而,通过UPSS评估的增粗程度在CMT患者中比其他疾病更为显著(CMT患者的UPSS中位数为18,而CIDP/MADSAM/MMN患者分别为11/8.5/5,p<0.001)。CMT患者中更常出现均匀性增粗(67%,HS为6,而免疫介导的周围神经病患者为2 - 3,p<0.001),而在CIDP患者中,增粗表现为区域性、均匀性或不均匀性,且比例相当。在MMN和MADSAM患者中,除正常节段(约20%)外,区域性增粗(48%/40%)占主导(MMN的RNEI = 2,MADSAM的RNEI = 1,其他疾病为0)。横截面积与运动传导速度呈负相关。
通过UPSS、HS和RNEI进行量化的超声检查,利用临界值有助于对免疫性神经病和遗传性神经病进行可靠且可重复的鉴别。
与仅测量横截面积相比,使用定量评分使脱髓鞘性神经病的超声鉴别更具操作性且得到改善。