Dickman Samuel L, Woolhandler Steffie, Bor Jacob, McCormick Danny, Bor David H, Himmelstein David U
Samuel L. Dickman (
Steffie Woolhandler is a professor of health policy at Hunter College, City University of New York, in New York City, and a lecturer in medicine at Harvard Medical School.
Health Aff (Millwood). 2016 Jul 1;35(7):1189-96. doi: 10.1377/hlthaff.2015.1024.
US medical spending growth slowed between 2004 and 2013. At the same time, many Americans faced rising copayments and deductibles, which may have particularly affected lower-income people. To explore whether the health spending slowdown affected all income groups equally, we divided the population into income quintiles. We then assessed trends in health expenditures by and on behalf of people in each quintile using twenty-two national surveys carried out between 1963 and 2012. Before the 1965 passage of legislation creating Medicare and Medicaid, the lowest income quintile had the lowest expenditures, despite their worse health compared to other income groups. By 1977 the unadjusted expenditures for the lowest quintile exceeded those for all other income groups. This pattern persisted until 2004. Thereafter, expenditures fell for the lowest quintile, while rising more than 10 percent for the middle three quintiles and close to 20 percent for the highest income quintile, which had the highest expenditures in 2012. The post-2004 divergence of expenditure trends for the wealthy, middle class, and poor occurred only among the nonelderly. We conclude that the new pattern of spending post-2004, with the wealthiest quintile having the highest expenditures for health care, suggests that a redistribution of care toward wealthier Americans accompanied the health spending slowdown.
2004年至2013年间,美国医疗支出增长放缓。与此同时,许多美国人面临着共付额和免赔额的增加,这可能对低收入人群影响尤甚。为探究医疗支出放缓是否对所有收入群体产生同等影响,我们将人口划分为五个收入五分位数组。然后,我们利用1963年至2012年间开展的22项全国性调查,评估了每个五分位数组人群及其代表的医疗支出趋势。在1965年创建医疗保险和医疗补助的立法通过之前,尽管最低收入五分位数组人群的健康状况比其他收入群体更差,但其支出却是最低的。到1977年,最低五分位数组未经调整的支出超过了所有其他收入群体。这种模式一直持续到2004年。此后,最低五分位数组的支出下降,而中间三个五分位数组的支出增长超过10%,最高收入五分位数组的支出增长近20%,该组在2012年的支出最高。2004年后富人群体、中产阶级和贫困群体支出趋势的差异仅出现在非老年人中。我们得出结论,2004年后出现的新支出模式,即最富有的五分位数组在医疗保健方面支出最高,这表明在医疗支出放缓的同时,医疗资源向更富有的美国人重新分配。