Sargent Randall, Brocklebank Cynthia, Tam-Tham Helen, Williamson Tyler, Quail Patrick, Turner Diana, Drummond Neil
Family Medicine and Primary Care Research Office, Cumming School of Medicine, University of Calgary, Calgary;; Integrated Supportive and Facility Living, Alberta Health Services, Calgary;; Southern Alberta Primary Care Research Network, University of Calgary, Calgary;
Pharmacy Services, Alberta Health Services, Edmonton;
Can Geriatr J. 2016 Jun 29;19(2):40-9. doi: 10.5770/cgj.19.205. eCollection 2016 Jun.
Warfarin is an anticoagulant prescribed to 12% of long-term care residents to reduce the risk of thrombo-embolism. This study used indicators to compare warfarin management by pharmacists to usual care.
This was a retrospective cohort study comparing a pharmacist-managed warfarin protocol with usual care of qualified warfarin recipients at long-term care facilities (two protocol, one control) in Calgary, Alberta. We compared the proportion of international normalized ratio (INR) tests in the range 2.0 to 3.0, time in range, number of tests, and frequency of bleeding at protocol and control sites. Our primary outcome, time in INR therapeutic range, is an indicator for assuring care quality. A cross-sectional survey at these sites compared health professionals' perceptions of workload and effectiveness of warfarin management.
Of the 197 residents' charts reviewed in the study period, those on protocol had 45.0 INR tests while those on usual care had 52.7 tests (p = .034, 95% CI for the difference: 0.6 to 14.6 INR tests). No significant difference was found for time in therapeutic range, number of tests in range, or major bleeding events. Of 178 health professionals surveyed, those from protocol facilities were more satisfied with warfarin management (p = .013). Workload and safety were perceived similarly at all sites.
Our results suggest that a pharmacist-managed warfarin protocol is as effective as usual care and has advantages pertaining to work satisfaction, knowledge of drug interactions, consistent documentation, and fewer INR tests. Further research on teamwork and coagulation management in long-term care facilities is recommended.
华法林是一种抗凝剂,12%的长期护理机构居民会使用它来降低血栓栓塞风险。本研究使用指标对比了药剂师对华法林的管理与常规护理。
这是一项回顾性队列研究,在艾伯塔省卡尔加里的长期护理机构(两个试验组,一个对照组)中,将药剂师管理的华法林方案与合格华法林接受者的常规护理进行比较。我们对比了国际标准化比值(INR)在2.0至3.0范围内的检测比例、处于该范围的时间、检测次数以及试验组和对照组的出血频率。我们的主要结局指标,即INR处于治疗范围内的时间,是确保护理质量的一项指标。在这些机构进行的横断面调查对比了卫生专业人员对工作量和华法林管理有效性的看法。
在研究期间审查的197份居民病历中,采用方案管理的居民进行了45.0次INR检测,而接受常规护理的居民进行了52.7次检测(p = 0.034,差异的95%置信区间:0.6至14.6次INR检测)。在治疗范围内的时间、范围内的检测次数或重大出血事件方面未发现显著差异。在接受调查的178名卫生专业人员中,来自采用方案管理机构的人员对华法林管理更满意(p = 0.013)。所有机构对工作量和安全性的看法相似。
我们的结果表明,药剂师管理的华法林方案与常规护理同样有效,并且在工作满意度、药物相互作用知识、一致的记录以及较少的INR检测方面具有优势。建议对长期护理机构中的团队合作和凝血管理进行进一步研究。