Gorokhova Elena, Lehtiniemi Maiju, Postel Lutz, Rubene Gunta, Amid Callis, Lesutiene Jurate, Uusitalo Laura, Strake Solvita, Demereckiene Natalja
Department of Environmental Science and Analytical Chemistry, Stockholm University, Stockholm, Sweden.
Finnish Environment Institute, Marine Research Center, Helsinki, Finland.
PLoS One. 2016 Jul 13;11(7):e0158326. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0158326. eCollection 2016.
The European Marine Strategy Framework Directive requires the EU Member States to estimate the level of anthropogenic impacts on their marine systems using 11 Descriptors. Assessing food web response to altered habitats is addressed by Descriptor 4 and its indicators, which are being developed for regional seas. However, the development of simple foodweb indicators able to assess the health of ecologically diverse, spatially variable and complex interactions is challenging. Zooplankton is a key element in marine foodwebs and thus comprise an important part of overall ecosystem health. Here, we review work on zooplankton indicator development using long-term data sets across the Baltic Sea and report the main findings. A suite of zooplankton community metrics were evaluated as putative ecological indicators that track community state in relation to Good Environmental Status (GES) criteria with regard to eutrophication and fish feeding conditions in the Baltic Sea. On the basis of an operational definition of GES, we propose mean body mass of zooplankton in the community in combination with zooplankton stock measured as either abundance or biomass to be applicable as an integrated indicator that could be used within the Descriptor 4 in the Baltic Sea. These metrics performed best in predicting zooplankton being in-GES when considering all datasets evaluated. However, some other metrics, such as copepod biomass, the contribution of copepods to the total zooplankton biomass or biomass-based Cladocera: Copepoda ratio, were equally reliable or even superior in certain basin-specific assessments. Our evaluation suggests that in several basins of the Baltic Sea, zooplankton communities currently appear to be out-of-GES, being comprised by smaller zooplankters and having lower total abundance or biomass compared to the communities during the reference conditions; however, the changes in the taxonomic structure underlying these trends vary widely across the sea basins due to the estuarine character of the Baltic Sea.
《欧洲海洋战略框架指令》要求欧盟成员国使用11项描述符来评估人为活动对其海洋系统的影响程度。描述符4及其指标涉及评估食物网对栖息地变化的响应,目前正在为各区域海洋制定这些指标。然而,开发能够评估生态多样、空间多变且复杂相互作用的健康状况的简单食物网指标具有挑战性。浮游动物是海洋食物网的关键要素,因此是整体生态系统健康的重要组成部分。在此,我们回顾了利用波罗的海长期数据集开展的浮游动物指标开发工作,并报告主要研究结果。我们评估了一系列浮游动物群落指标,将其作为推定的生态指标,以追踪与波罗的海富营养化和鱼类摄食条件相关的良好环境状况(GES)标准下的群落状态。基于GES的操作性定义,我们建议将群落中浮游动物的平均体重与以丰度或生物量衡量的浮游动物存量相结合,作为一个综合指标应用于波罗的海描述符4中。在考虑所有评估数据集时,这些指标在预测浮游动物处于GES状态方面表现最佳。然而,在某些特定流域评估中,其他一些指标,如桡足类生物量、桡足类在总浮游动物生物量中的占比或以生物量为基础的枝角类:桡足类比率,同样可靠甚至更优。我们的评估表明,在波罗的海的几个流域,目前浮游动物群落似乎未处于GES状态,与参考条件下的群落相比,其由体型较小的浮游动物组成,总丰度或生物量较低;然而,由于波罗的海的河口特征,这些趋势背后的分类结构变化在不同海域差异很大。