Burgess Adrian P, Fouquet Nathalie C, Seri Stefano, Hawken Malcolm B, Heard Andrew, Neasham David, Little Mark P, Elliott Paul
Aston Brain Centre, School of Life & Health Sciences, School of Life & Health Sciences, Aston University, Birmingham B4 7ET, UK.
Aston Brain Centre, School of Life & Health Sciences, School of Life & Health Sciences, Aston University, Birmingham B4 7ET, UK.
Environ Res. 2016 Oct;150:461-469. doi: 10.1016/j.envres.2016.06.031. Epub 2016 Jul 13.
Terrestrial Trunked Radio (TETRA) is a telecommunications system widely used by police and emergency services around the world. The Stewart Report on mobile telephony and health raised questions about possible health effects associated with TETRA signals. This study investigates possible effects of TETRA signals on the electroencephalogram and electrocardiogram in human volunteers.
Blinded randomized provocation study with a standardized TETRA signal or sham exposure. In the first of two experiments, police officers had a TETRA set placed first against the left temple and then the upper-left quadrant of the chest and the electroencephalogram was recorded during rest and active cognitive processing. In the second experiment, volunteers were subject to chest exposure of TETRA whilst their electroencephalogram and heart rate variability derived from the electrocardiogram were recorded.
In the first experiment, we found that exposure to TETRA had consistent neurophysiological effects on the electroencephalogram, but only during chest exposure, in a pattern suggestive of vagal nerve stimulation. In the second experiment, we observed changes in heart rate variability during exposure to TETRA but the electroencephalogram effects were not replicated.
Observed effects of exposure to TETRA signals on the electroencephalogram (first experiment) and electrocardiogram are consistent with vagal nerve stimulation in the chest by TETRA. However given the small effect on heart rate variability and the lack of consistency on the electroencephalogram, it seems unlikely that this will have a significant impact on health. Long-term monitoring of the health of the police force in relation to TETRA use is on-going.
陆地集群无线电(TETRA)是一种在全球范围内被警察和应急服务部门广泛使用的电信系统。关于移动电话与健康的斯图尔特报告对与TETRA信号相关的潜在健康影响提出了疑问。本研究调查了TETRA信号对人类志愿者脑电图和心电图的可能影响。
采用标准化TETRA信号或假暴露进行盲法随机激发研究。在两项实验的第一项中,警官们先将一台TETRA设备靠在左太阳穴处,然后放在胸部左上象限,在休息和积极认知处理过程中记录脑电图。在第二项实验中,志愿者在胸部暴露于TETRA信号的同时,记录他们的脑电图和从心电图得出的心率变异性。
在第一项实验中,我们发现暴露于TETRA对脑电图有一致的神经生理影响,但仅在胸部暴露期间,呈现出迷走神经刺激的模式。在第二项实验中,我们观察到暴露于TETRA期间心率变异性发生了变化,但脑电图的影响未得到重复。
观察到的暴露于TETRA信号对脑电图(第一项实验)和心电图的影响与TETRA对胸部迷走神经的刺激一致。然而,鉴于对心率变异性的影响较小且脑电图缺乏一致性,这似乎不太可能对健康产生重大影响。目前正在对警察部队与TETRA使用相关的健康状况进行长期监测。