Pitkälä Kaisu H, Suominen Merja H, Bell J Simon, Strandberg Timo E
a Department of General Practice and Primary Health Care , Helsinki , Finland.
b Unit of Primary Health Care, University of Helsinki, and Helsinki University Hospital , Helsinki , Finland.
Ann Med. 2016 Dec;48(8):586-602. doi: 10.1080/07853890.2016.1197414. Epub 2016 Jul 16.
Evidence for the safety and effectiveness of dietary supplements is mixed. The extent to which older people use dietary supplements concomitantly with conventional medications is often under-appreciated by physicians. We conducted a literature review on clinical considerations associated with dietary supplement use, focusing on benefits and harms, motivations for use and contribution to polypharmacy among older people. Vitamin D ≥ 800 IU has demonstrated benefits in fracture prevention. Vitamins A, E, and β-carotene have been associated with an increase in total mortality in several meta-analyses. A range of non-vitamin dietary supplements have been studied in randomized controlled trials but their efficacy remains largely unclear. Supplement use has been associated with a range of adverse events and drug interactions yet physicians rarely initiate discussions about their use with older patients. Older people may take dietary supplements to exercise control over their health. Given the contribution of supplements to polypharmacy, supplements may be targeted for "deprescribing" if the risk of harm is judged to outweigh benefits. This is best done as part of a comprehensive, patient-centered approach. A respectful and non-judgmental discussion may result in a shared decision to reduce polypharmacy through cessation of dietary supplements. KEY MESSAGES Herbal medications and other dietary supplements are highly prevalent among older people. Physicians are often unaware that their patients use herbal medications and other dietary supplements concomitantly with conventional medications. Herbal medications and other dietary supplements contribute to high rates of polypharmacy, particularly among older people with multimorbidity. Herbal medications and other dietary supplements can interact with conventional medications and be associated with a range of adverse events. Physicians need to be patient-centered and non-judgmental when initiating discussions about herbal medications and other dietary supplements. This is important to maintain and develop patient empowerment and self-management skills.
膳食补充剂安全性和有效性的证据参差不齐。医生常常未充分认识到老年人同时使用膳食补充剂和传统药物的情况。我们针对与膳食补充剂使用相关的临床考量进行了文献综述,重点关注老年人使用膳食补充剂的益处和危害、动机以及对多重用药的影响。维生素D≥800国际单位已证明对预防骨折有益。在多项荟萃分析中,维生素A、E和β-胡萝卜素与总死亡率增加有关。一系列非维生素类膳食补充剂已在随机对照试验中进行了研究,但其疗效仍基本不明确。补充剂的使用与一系列不良事件和药物相互作用有关,但医生很少与老年患者展开关于其使用的讨论。老年人可能会服用膳食补充剂来掌控自身健康。鉴于补充剂对多重用药的影响,如果判断危害风险超过益处,补充剂可能会成为“停药”的目标。最好将此作为全面的、以患者为中心的方法的一部分来进行。一次尊重且不带评判的讨论可能会促成共同决定,即通过停用膳食补充剂来减少多重用药。关键信息草药和其他膳食补充剂在老年人中非常普遍。医生常常不知道他们的患者同时使用草药和其他膳食补充剂与传统药物。草药和其他膳食补充剂导致多重用药率很高,尤其是在患有多种疾病的老年人中。草药和其他膳食补充剂可能与传统药物相互作用,并与一系列不良事件有关。医生在开始讨论草药和其他膳食补充剂时需要以患者为中心且不带评判。这对于维持和培养患者的自主权及自我管理技能很重要。