Diamond-Smith Nadia, Sudhinaraset May, Melo Jason, Murthy Nirmala
University of California, San Francisco, 550 16th Street, 3rd Floor, Box 1224, San Francisco, CA 94158, United States.
Foundation for Research in Health Systems, G-1, Brigade Bussiness Suites, 44, T.Mariappa Road, 100 feet Road, Jayanagar 2nd Block, Bangalore 560011, India.
Midwifery. 2016 Sep;40:114-23. doi: 10.1016/j.midw.2016.06.014. Epub 2016 Jun 23.
a growing body of literature has highlighted the prevalence of mistreatment that women experience around the globe during childbirth, including verbal and physical abuse, neglect, lack of support, and disrespect. Much of this has been qualitative. Research around the world suggests that support during childbirth can improve health outcomes and behaviours, and improve experiences. Support can be instrumental, informational, or emotional, and can be provided by a variety of people including family (husbands, mothers) or health providers of various professional levels. This study explores women's reported experiences of mistreatment during childbirth quantitatively, and how these varied by specific types of support available and provided by specific individuals.
participants were women age 16-30 who had delivered infants in a health facility in the previous five years and were living in slums of Lucknow India. Data were collected on their experiences of mistreatment, the types of support they received, and who provided that support.
women who reported lack of support were more likely to report mistreatment. Lack of support in regards to discussions with providers and provider information were most strongly associated with a higher mistreatment score. Women who received any type of support from their husband or a health worker were significantly more likely to report lower mistreatment scores. Receiving informational support from a mother/mother-in-law or emotional support from a health worker was also associated with lower mistreatment scores. However, receiving emotional support from a friend/neighbour/other family member was associated with a higher mistreatment score.
women rely on different people to provide different types of support during childbirth in this setting. Some of these individuals provide specific types of support that ultimately improve a woman's overall experience of her childbirth. Interventions aiming to reduce mistreatment to women during childbirth should consider the important role of increasing support for women, and who might be the most appropriate person to provide the most essential types of support through this process.
越来越多的文献强调了全球女性在分娩期间遭受虐待的普遍性,包括言语和身体虐待、忽视、缺乏支持以及不尊重。其中大部分是定性研究。世界各地的研究表明,分娩期间的支持可以改善健康结果和行为,并提升体验。支持可以是工具性的、信息性的或情感性的,并且可以由包括家人(丈夫、母亲)或不同专业水平的医疗服务提供者在内的各种人提供。本研究定量探讨了女性报告的分娩期间遭受虐待的经历,以及这些经历如何因特定类型的可用支持和特定个人提供的支持而有所不同。
参与者为年龄在16至30岁之间、过去五年内在印度勒克瑙贫民窟的医疗机构分娩过婴儿的女性。收集了她们遭受虐待的经历、所获得的支持类型以及提供支持的人员的数据。
报告缺乏支持的女性更有可能报告遭受虐待。在与医疗服务提供者的讨论和提供者信息方面缺乏支持与更高的虐待得分最密切相关。从丈夫或医护人员那里获得任何一种支持的女性报告较低虐待得分的可能性显著更高。从母亲/婆婆那里获得信息支持或从医护人员那里获得情感支持也与较低的虐待得分相关。然而,从朋友/邻居/其他家庭成员那里获得情感支持与更高的虐待得分相关。
在这种情况下,女性在分娩期间依赖不同的人提供不同类型的支持。其中一些人提供特定类型的支持,最终改善了女性的整体分娩体验。旨在减少女性分娩期间虐待行为的干预措施应考虑增加对女性支持的重要作用,以及在这个过程中谁可能是提供最基本支持类型的最合适人选。