Pütter Carolin, Stausberg Jürgen, von Beckerath Olga, Reinecke Holger, Schäfer Erika, Kröger Knut
1 Institute of Medical Informatic, Epidemiology and Biometry, University Duisburg Essen, Germany.
2 Department of Vascular Medicine, HELIOS Klinik Krefeld, Germany.
Vasa. 2016;45(4):311-5. doi: 10.1024/0301-1526/a000543.
We analysed a potential association between the decrease in major amputations in Germany and the number of doctors, prescribed podologic foot care (PFC) and antidiabetic drugs, and performed percutaneous endoluminal angioplasties (PTA).
Data of all lower limb major amputations between 2007 and 2011, the cases hospitalised with an additional diagnosis of diabetes mellitus, and the numbers of PTAs, and the number of doctors in private practices and in hospitals were obtained from the Federal Statistical Office. Furthermore, the number of PFC treatments and prescribed antidiabetics for each of the five years were derived from the federal report of the statutory health insurance.
Within the 5 year time period, major amputations decreased by 19.0%, from 17,846 in 2007 to 14,463 in 2011. There is an inverse relation between the number of major amputations and the increasing number of prescribed PFC, of doctors working in hospital and of below-the-knee PTA in the multiple Poisson regression analysis. The number of prescribed antidiabetics and that of all PTA showed a positive relation. In the multiple linear regression analysis with the dependent variable ratio of amputations and the cases hospitalised with an additional diagnosis of diabetes mellitus, only numbers of prescribed PFC and below-the-knee PTA still showed an inverse relation that reached a level of significance.
While substantial improvements in patients care by doctors, endovascular interventions, prescriptions of PFC and antidiabetic drugs are under discussion to reduce major amputation rates, in this approach including comprehensive data from Germany, only prescriptions of PFC and the number of below-the-knee PTA had an independent and significant impact on the reduction of major amputations. It has to be pointed out that such a statistical association does not prove any causality.
我们分析了德国大截肢手术数量的减少与医生数量、开具的足部护理(PFC)和抗糖尿病药物的数量以及进行经皮腔内血管成形术(PTA)之间的潜在关联。
从联邦统计局获取了2007年至2011年间所有下肢大截肢手术的数据、额外诊断为糖尿病的住院病例数据、PTA的数量以及私人诊所和医院的医生数量。此外,五年中每年的PFC治疗次数和开具的抗糖尿病药物数量来自法定健康保险的联邦报告。
在5年时间内,大截肢手术数量减少了19.0%,从2007年的17,846例降至2011年的14,463例。在多元泊松回归分析中,大截肢手术数量与开具的PFC数量增加、医院工作的医生数量增加以及膝下PTA数量增加之间存在负相关关系。开具的抗糖尿病药物数量与所有PTA数量之间呈正相关关系。在以截肢与额外诊断为糖尿病的住院病例的比例为因变量的多元线性回归分析中,只有开具的PFC数量和膝下PTA数量仍显示出达到显著水平的负相关关系。
虽然医生的患者护理、血管内介入治疗、PFC和抗糖尿病药物的处方在减少大截肢率方面有显著改善,但在这种纳入德国综合数据的方法中,只有PFC处方和膝下PTA数量对大截肢手术数量的减少有独立且显著的影响。必须指出的是,这种统计关联并不能证明任何因果关系。