Baring Ryan J, Lester Rebecca E, Fairweather Peter G
School of Biological Sciences, Flinders University, GPO Box 2100, Adelaide, SA, 5001, Australia.
School of Life and Environmental Sciences, Deakin University, P.O. Box 423, Warrnambool, Victoria, 3280, Australia.
Mar Environ Res. 2016 Sep;120:68-77. doi: 10.1016/j.marenvres.2016.07.003. Epub 2016 Jul 9.
Exploratory investigations of optimal sampling designs are a critical component of the decision-making process in ecology where inherent natural variation can lead to erroneous conclusions if left unexamined. Pilot studies and exploratory analyses that investigate the precision of sampling regimes may reduce the chances of erroneous results and can be used to optimise processing time in larger ecological research programs. In our study, we calculated optimal precision estimates for sampling macroinvertebrates and ichthyofauna in surf-zone wrack accumulations by investigating the precision of the mean for sub-samples of seine nets and also for the number of replicate seine nets to guide future sampling regimes. We discovered that the processing time for individual seine net samples could be reduced by 50% using sub-sampling and that time to process replicate seine net samples could be reduced by 25% while maintaining acceptable precision. In future, we suggest that the use of pilot studies with similar exploratory approaches should be less of an exception and more a critical component of ecological investigations, particularly in under-studied or newly-developing areas of research. Further, these types of exploratory approaches are crucially important in a variety of extremely patchy environments where variability is likely to be high.
探索最优抽样设计是生态学决策过程的关键组成部分,在生态学中,如果不考虑固有的自然变异,可能会导致错误的结论。研究抽样方案精度的初步研究和探索性分析可以减少得出错误结果的可能性,并可用于优化大型生态研究项目的处理时间。在我们的研究中,通过研究围网子网样本均值的精度以及重复围网的数量,我们计算了在冲浪区残骸堆积物中对大型无脊椎动物和鱼类进行抽样的最优精度估计,以指导未来的抽样方案。我们发现,使用子抽样可以将单个围网样本的处理时间减少50%,并且在保持可接受精度的同时,处理重复围网样本的时间可以减少25%。未来,我们建议采用类似探索性方法的初步研究不应只是例外,而应更多地成为生态调查的关键组成部分,特别是在研究不足或新发展的研究领域。此外,这些类型的探索性方法在各种极端斑块状且变异性可能很高的环境中至关重要。