Maron-Katz Adi, Amar David, Simon Eti Ben, Hendler Talma, Shamir Ron
Functional Brain Center, Wohl Institute for Advanced Imaging Tel-Aviv Sourasky Medical Center, Tel Aviv, Israel.
Sackler Faculty of Medicine, Tel Aviv University, Tel Aviv, Israel.
PLoS One. 2016 Jul 25;11(7):e0159643. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0159643. eCollection 2016.
As the use of large-scale data-driven analysis becomes increasingly common, the need for robust methods for interpreting a large number of results increases. To date, neuroimaging attempts to interpret large-scale activity or connectivity results often turn to existing neural mapping based on previous literature. In case of a large number of results, manual selection or percent of overlap with existing maps is frequently used to facilitate interpretation, often without a clear statistical justification. Such methodology holds the risk of reporting false positive results and overlooking additional results. Here, we propose using enrichment analysis for improving the interpretation of large-scale neuroimaging results. We focus on two possible cases: position group analysis, where the identified results are a set of neural positions; and connection group analysis, where the identified results are a set of neural position-pairs (i.e. neural connections). We explore different models for detecting significant overrepresentation of known functional brain annotations using simulated and real data. We implemented our methods in a tool called RichMind, which provides both statistical significance reports and brain visualization. We demonstrate the abilities of RichMind by revisiting two previous fMRI studies. In both studies RichMind automatically highlighted most of the findings that were reported in the original studies as well as several additional findings that were overlooked. Hence, RichMind is a valuable new tool for rigorous inference from neuroimaging results.
随着大规模数据驱动分析的应用日益普遍,对用于解释大量结果的可靠方法的需求也在增加。迄今为止,神经影像学在尝试解释大规模活动或连接结果时,常常求助于基于以往文献的现有神经图谱。在面对大量结果时,人们经常使用手动选择或与现有图谱的重叠百分比来辅助解释,而这往往缺乏明确的统计依据。这种方法存在报告假阳性结果和忽略其他结果的风险。在此,我们提出使用富集分析来改进对大规模神经影像学结果的解释。我们聚焦于两种可能的情况:位置组分析,即所识别的结果是一组神经位置;以及连接组分析,即所识别的结果是一组神经位置对(即神经连接)。我们使用模拟数据和真实数据探索了不同的模型,以检测已知功能脑注释的显著过度表征。我们在一个名为RichMind的工具中实现了我们的方法,该工具既提供统计显著性报告,又能进行脑可视化。我们通过回顾之前的两项功能磁共振成像(fMRI)研究来展示RichMind的能力。在这两项研究中,RichMind自动突出显示了原始研究中报告的大部分发现以及一些被忽略的其他发现。因此,RichMind是从神经影像学结果进行严格推断的一个有价值的新工具。