Agha Sohail, Tappis Hannah
The Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation, P.O. Box 23350, WA 98102, Seattle, Washington, USA.
Jhpiego - an affiliate of Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, Maryland, USA.
BMC Pregnancy Childbirth. 2016 Jul 27;16(1):190. doi: 10.1186/s12884-016-0979-8.
Policymakers and program planners consider antenatal care (ANC) coverage to be a primary measure of improvements in maternal health. Yet, evidence from multiple countries indicates that ANC coverage has no necessary relationship with the content of services provided. This study examines the relationship between the timing of the first ANC check-up, a potential predictor of the content of services, and the provision of WHO recommended services to women during their pregnancy.
The study uses data from a representative household survey of Sindh with a sample comprising of 4,000 women aged 15-49 who had had a live birth in the two years before the survey. The survey obtained information about the elements of care provided during pregnancy, the timing of the first ANC check-up, the number of ANC visits made during the last pregnancy and women's socio-economic and demographic characteristics. Bivariate analysis was conducted to examine the relationship between the proportion of women who receive six WHO recommended services and the timing of their first ANC check-up. Multivariate analysis was conducted to identify predictors of the number of elements of care provided.
While most women in Sindh (87 %) receive an ANC check-up, its timing varies by parity, education and household wealth. The median time to the first ANC check-up was 3 months for women in the richest and 7 months for women in the poorest wealth quintiles. In multivariate analysis, wealth, education, parity and age at marriage were significant predictors of the number of elements of care provided. Women who received an early ANC check-up were much more likely to receive WHO recommended services than other women, independent of a range of socio-economic and demographic variables and independent of the number of ANC visits made during pregnancy.
In Sindh, the timing of the first ANC check-up has an independent effect on the content of care provided to pregnant women. While it is extremely important that providers are adequately trained and motivated to provide the WHO recommended standards of care, these findings suggest that motivating women to make an early first ANC check-up may be another mechanism through which the quality of care provided may be improved. Such a focus is most likely to benefit the poorest, least educated and highest parity women. Based on these findings, we recommend that routine data collected at health facilities in Pakistan should include the month of pregnancy at the time of the first ANC check-up.
政策制定者和项目规划者将产前保健(ANC)覆盖率视为孕产妇健康改善的主要衡量指标。然而,多个国家的证据表明,ANC覆盖率与所提供服务的内容没有必然联系。本研究考察首次ANC检查时间(服务内容的一个潜在预测因素)与孕期向妇女提供世界卫生组织(WHO)推荐服务之间的关系。
本研究使用来自信德省一项具有代表性的家庭调查数据,样本包括4000名年龄在15 - 49岁之间、在调查前两年内有过活产的妇女。该调查获取了孕期所提供护理内容、首次ANC检查时间、上次孕期进行的ANC检查次数以及妇女的社会经济和人口统计学特征等信息。进行双变量分析以考察接受六项WHO推荐服务的妇女比例与其首次ANC检查时间之间的关系。进行多变量分析以确定所提供护理项目数量的预测因素。
虽然信德省的大多数妇女(87%)接受了ANC检查,但其时间因胎次、教育程度和家庭财富而异。最富裕五分位组妇女首次ANC检查的中位时间为3个月,最贫穷五分位组妇女为7个月。在多变量分析中,财富、教育程度、胎次和结婚年龄是所提供护理项目数量的显著预测因素。与其他妇女相比,早期接受ANC检查的妇女更有可能接受WHO推荐的服务,这与一系列社会经济和人口统计学变量无关,也与孕期进行的ANC检查次数无关。
在信德省,首次ANC检查时间对向孕妇提供的护理内容有独立影响。虽然提供者接受充分培训并有动力提供WHO推荐的护理标准极其重要,但这些发现表明,激励妇女尽早进行首次ANC检查可能是提高所提供护理质量的另一种机制。这样的重点最有可能使最贫穷、受教育程度最低和胎次最高的妇女受益。基于这些发现,我们建议巴基斯坦卫生机构收集的常规数据应包括首次ANC检查时的孕周。