Lakhani Anand, Lass Elliot, Silverstein William K, Born Karen B, Levinson Wendy, Wong Brian M
A. Lakhani is a second-year medical student, University of Toronto, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.E. Lass is a third-year medical student, University of Toronto, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.W.K. Silverstein is a third-year medical student, University of Toronto, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.K.B. Born is knowledge translation lead, Choosing Wisely Canada, and assistant professor, Institute of Health Policy, Management and Evaluation, University of Toronto, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.W. Levinson is chair, Choosing Wisely Canada, and professor of medicine, University of Toronto, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.B.M. Wong is medical education lead, Choosing Wisely Canada, and associate professor of medicine, Department of Medicine, University of Toronto, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
Acad Med. 2016 Oct;91(10):1374-1378. doi: 10.1097/ACM.0000000000001325.
Physician behaviors that promote overuse of health care resources develop early in training, and the medical education environment helps foster such behaviors. The authors describe the development of a Choosing Wisely list for medical students aimed at helping to curb overuse.
The list was developed in 2015 by Choosing Wisely Canada (CWC) in partnership with the Canadian Federation of Medical Students and the Fédération médicale étudiante du Québec, which together represent all medical students in Canada. CWC convened a student-led taskforce to develop recommendations targeting medical student behaviors with respect to resource stewardship practices. Students at all 17 Canadian medical schools were consulted via an online questionnaire to solicit feedback on a list of 10 candidate recommendations. The taskforce used this student feedback in finalizing the list.
The final list of "Six Things That Medical Students and Trainees Should Question" highlights both behaviors students should avoid (e.g., "Don't suggest ordering the most invasive test before considering other less invasive options") and behaviors related to aspects of medical training that may promote overuse, such as the hierarchical nature of clinical supervision (e.g., "Don't hesitate to ask for clarification on tests, treatments, or procedures that you believe may be ordered inappropriately"). Based on student requests for illustrative examples, clinical vignettes were developed.
This list highlights medical student behaviors and aspects of the academic environment that drive overuse. It is also relevant to faculty, whose behaviors and supervision practices influence trainees.
促进医疗资源过度使用的医生行为在培训早期就已形成,而医学教育环境助长了此类行为。作者描述了一份面向医学生的“明智选择”清单的制定情况,旨在帮助遏制过度使用。
该清单由加拿大明智选择组织(CWC)于2015年与加拿大医学生联合会及魁北克医学生联合会合作制定,这两个组织共同代表了加拿大所有医学生。CWC召集了一个由学生主导的特别工作组,针对医学生在资源管理实践方面的行为制定建议。通过在线问卷咨询了加拿大所有17所医学院的学生,以征求他们对一份包含10条候选建议清单的反馈。特别工作组利用这些学生反馈确定了最终清单。
最终的“医学生和实习生应质疑的六件事”清单既强调了学生应避免的行为(例如,“在考虑其他侵入性较小的选项之前,不要建议进行侵入性最强的检查”),也强调了与可能促进过度使用的医学培训方面相关的行为,比如临床监督的等级性质(例如,“对于你认为可能被不恰当地安排的检查、治疗或程序,要毫不犹豫地要求澄清”)。根据学生对示例的要求,编写了临床案例。
这份清单突出了导致过度使用的医学生行为和学术环境方面。它对教师也有参考价值,因为教师的行为和监督做法会影响实习生。