Faculty of Medicine, Dalhousie University, Nova Scotia, Canada.
Research Methods University, Nova Scotia Health, Nova Scotia, Canada.
Can Med Educ J. 2023 Jun 27;14(3):14-32. doi: 10.36834/cmej.74645. eCollection 2023 Jun.
Medical student investment in resource stewardship (RS) is essential as resource overuse continues among physicians, but it is unclear whether this is influenced by hidden curriculum. This study investigated medical student perceptions of Choosing Wisely Canada (CWC).
Canadian Medical students completed a bilingual questionnaire. Chi-square and student's T-tests were used to analyze Likert responses capturing student attitudes toward questions grouped by theme, including the importance of the CWC campaign, the amount of CWC represented in undergraduate medical curriculum, the application of CWC recommendations in medicine, and the barriers which exist to student advocacy for CWC in practice.
There were 3,239/11,754 (26.9%) respondents. While most students ( = 2,720/3,171; 85.8%) endorsed the importance of CWC, few students felt that their institution had sufficiently integrated CWC into pre-clerkship (47.0%) and clerkship (63.5%) curricula. Overall, 61.4% of students felt that it is reasonable to expect physicians to apply CWC recommendations given the workplace culture in medicine. Only 35.1% students were comfortable addressing resource misuse with their preceptor. The most common barriers included the assumption that their preceptor was more knowledgeable (86.4%), concern over evaluations (66.0%), and concern for their reputation (31.2%).
Canadian medical students recognize the importance of CWC. However, many trainees feel that the workplace culture in medicine does not support the application of CWC recommendations. A power imbalance exists that prevents students from advocating for RS in practice.
由于医生过度用药的情况持续存在,医学生对资源管理的投入至关重要,但目前尚不清楚这是否受到隐性课程的影响。本研究调查了医学生对加拿大明智选择(Choosing Wisely Canada,CWC)的看法。
加拿大医学生完成了一份双语问卷。采用卡方检验和学生 t 检验分析了按主题分组的问题的李克特反应,包括 CWC 运动的重要性、本科医学课程中 CWC 的代表性、CWC 建议在医学中的应用,以及学生在实践中倡导 CWC 所存在的障碍。
共有 3239/11754(26.9%)名学生参与了研究。尽管大多数学生(=2720/3171;85.8%)认为 CWC 很重要,但很少有学生认为他们的机构已经充分将 CWC 融入预科(47.0%)和实习(63.5%)课程。总体而言,61.4%的学生认为,鉴于医学工作场所的文化,期望医生应用 CWC 建议是合理的。只有 35.1%的学生在与导师讨论资源滥用问题时感到自在。最常见的障碍包括假设导师更有知识(86.4%)、担心评估(66.0%)和担心自己的声誉(31.2%)。
加拿大医学生认识到 CWC 的重要性。然而,许多受训者认为医学工作场所的文化不支持 CWC 建议的应用。权力失衡使得学生无法在实践中倡导 RS。