Carpendale Jeremy I M, Hammond Stuart I
aDepartment of Psychology, Simon Fraser University, Burnaby, British Columbia bUniversity of Ottawa, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada.
Curr Opin Pediatr. 2016 Dec;28(6):743-747. doi: 10.1097/MOP.0000000000000412.
The review critically evaluates recent claims that infants have innate knowledge of morality and examines the sources of moral norms.
Many studies show that toddlers readily help adults with daily tasks. A more contentious set of studies suggests that young infants prefer actors who help others to those who hinder them. Some researchers have interpreted these findings as indicating that morality is innately present in humans. Others look to alternative explanations in developmental systems theory.
Explaining the emergence of morality as innate, or wholly socialized, is problematic; instead morality could emerge in a developmental system in which children's early capacities are shaped by interpersonal engagement. Children's improving ability to coordinate with others at a practical level is later transformed through language and reflective thought, as children gain the ability to talk about what was previously implicit in interaction. Throughout, parents and caregivers have many opportunities to foster children's moral development in daily interactions.
本综述批判性地评估了近期有关婴儿具有先天道德知识的说法,并探讨了道德规范的来源。
许多研究表明,幼儿很乐意帮助成年人完成日常任务。一系列更具争议性的研究表明,年幼儿童更喜欢帮助他人的行为者,而不是阻碍他人的行为者。一些研究人员将这些发现解释为表明道德在人类中是天生存在的。另一些人则在发展系统理论中寻找其他解释。
将道德的出现解释为天生的或完全社会化的是有问题的;相反,道德可能出现在一个发展系统中,在这个系统中,儿童的早期能力是通过人际互动形成的。随着儿童获得谈论之前互动中隐含内容的能力,他们在实际层面与他人协调的能力不断提高,随后通过语言和反思性思维得到转变。在整个过程中,父母和照顾者在日常互动中有很多机会促进儿童的道德发展。