Hajizadeh Roohalah, Golbabaei Farideh, Farhang Dehghan Somayeh, Beheshti Mohammad Hossein, Jafari Sayed Mohammad, Taheri Fereshteh
Occupational Health Research Center, Qom University of Medical Sciences, Qom, Iran.
Department of Occupational Health, School of Public Health, Tehran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran.
J Res Health Sci. 2016 Spring;16(2):90-5.
Necessity of evaluating heat stress in the workplace, require validation of indices and selection optimal index. The present study aimed to assess the precision and validity of some heat stress indices and select the optimum index for using in heavy work activities in hot and dry climates.
It carried out on 184 workers from 40 brick kilns workshops in the city of Qom, central Iran (as representative hot and dry climates). After reviewing the working process and evaluation the activity of workers and the type of work, environmental and physiological parameters according to standards recommended by International Organization for Standardization (ISO) including ISO 7243 and ISO 9886 were measured and indices were calculated.
Workers engaged in indoor kiln experienced the highest values of natural wet temperature, dry temperature, globe temperature and relative humidity among studied sections (P<0.05). Indoor workplaces had the higher levels of all environmental parameters than outdoors (P=0.0001), except for air velocity. The wet-bulb globe temperature (WBGT) and heat stress index (HSI) indices had the highest correlation with other physiological parameters among the other heat stress indices. Relationship between WBGT index and carotid artery temperature (r=0.49), skin temperature (r=0.319), and oral temperature (r=0.203) was statistically significant (P=0.006).
Since WBGT index, as the most applicable index for evaluating heat stress in workplaces is approved by ISO, and due to the positive features of WBGT such as ease of measurement and calculation, and with respect to some limitation in application of HSI; WBGT can be introduced as the most valid empirical index of heat stress in the brick workshops.
评估工作场所热应激的必要性,需要对指标进行验证并选择最佳指标。本研究旨在评估一些热应激指标的准确性和有效性,并选择在炎热干燥气候下的繁重工作活动中使用的最佳指标。
对来自伊朗中部库姆市40个砖窑车间的184名工人进行了研究(作为炎热干燥气候的代表)。在审查工作流程并评估工人的活动和工作类型后,根据国际标准化组织(ISO)推荐的标准,包括ISO 7243和ISO 9886,测量了环境和生理参数并计算了指标。
在所研究的区域中,从事室内窑炉工作的工人的自然湿球温度、干球温度、黑球温度和相对湿度最高(P<0.05)。除风速外,室内工作场所的所有环境参数水平均高于室外(P=0.0001)。在其他热应激指标中,湿球黑球温度(WBGT)和热应激指数(HSI)与其他生理参数的相关性最高。WBGT指数与颈动脉温度(r=0.49)、皮肤温度(r=0.319)和口腔温度(r=0.203)之间的关系具有统计学意义(P=0.006)。
由于WBGT指数是ISO认可的评估工作场所热应激最适用的指标,并且由于WBGT具有易于测量和计算等积极特性,同时考虑到HSI在应用中的一些局限性;WBGT可被视为砖窑车间热应激最有效的经验指标。