Simmering Vanessa R
Monogr Soc Res Child Dev. 2016 Sep;81(3):7-24. doi: 10.1111/mono.12249.
Working memory is a vital cognitive skill that underlies a broad range of behaviors. Higher cognitive functions are reliably predicted by working memory measures from two domains: children's performance on complex span tasks, and infants' performance in looking paradigms. Despite the similar predictive power across these research areas, theories of working memory development have not connected these different task types and developmental periods. The current project takes a first step toward bridging this gap by presenting a process-oriented theory, focusing on two tasks designed to assess visual working memory capacity in infants (the change-preference task) versus children and adults (the change detection task). Previous studies have shown inconsistent results, with capacity estimates increasing from one to four items during infancy, but only two to three items during early childhood. A probable source of this discrepancy is the different task structures used with each age group, but prior theories were not sufficiently specific to explain how performance relates across tasks. The current theory focuses on cognitive dynamics, that is, how memory representations are formed, maintained, and used within specific task contexts over development. This theory was formalized in a computational model to generate three predictions: 1) capacity estimates in the change-preference task should continue to increase beyond infancy; 2) capacity estimates should be higher in the change-preference versus change detection task when tested within individuals; and 3) performance should correlate across tasks because both rely on the same underlying memory system. I also tested a fourth prediction, that development across tasks could be explained through increasing real-time stability, realized computationally as strengthening connectivity within the model. Results confirmed these predictions, supporting the cognitive dynamics account of performance and developmental changes in real-time stability. The monograph concludes with implications for understanding memory, behavior, and development in a broader range of cognitive development.
工作记忆是一种至关重要的认知技能,是广泛行为的基础。工作记忆的测量可以可靠地预测两种领域的高级认知功能:儿童在复杂跨度任务中的表现,以及婴儿在注视范式中的表现。尽管这些研究领域具有相似的预测能力,但工作记忆发展理论尚未将这些不同的任务类型和发展阶段联系起来。当前项目朝着弥合这一差距迈出了第一步,提出了一种以过程为导向的理论,重点关注旨在评估婴儿(变化偏好任务)与儿童及成人(变化检测任务)视觉工作记忆容量的两项任务。先前的研究结果并不一致,婴儿期的容量估计从一项增加到四项,但幼儿期仅为两项到三项。这种差异的一个可能来源是每个年龄组使用的不同任务结构,但先前的理论不够具体,无法解释不同任务之间的表现关系。当前理论关注认知动态,即记忆表征在整个发展过程中如何在特定任务背景下形成、维持和使用。该理论在一个计算模型中得到了形式化,以产生三个预测:1)变化偏好任务中的容量估计在婴儿期之后应继续增加;2)在个体测试中,变化偏好任务的容量估计应高于变化检测任务;3)两项任务的表现应具有相关性,因为两者都依赖于相同的潜在记忆系统。我还测试了第四个预测,即不同任务之间的发展可以通过实时稳定性的增加来解释,在计算上表现为模型内连接性的增强。结果证实了这些预测,支持了认知动态对表现和实时稳定性发展变化的解释。这本专著最后讨论了在更广泛的认知发展中理解记忆、行为和发展的意义。