Müller Lisa, Müller Erich, Hildebrandt Carolin, Raschner Christian
Department of Sport Science, University of Innsbruck, Innsbruck, Tyrol, Austria.
Department of Sport Science and Kinesiology, University of Salzburg, Salzburg, Salzburg, Austria.
PLoS One. 2016 Aug 9;11(8):e0160969. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0160969. eCollection 2016.
The relative age effect (RAE) is a well-documented phenomenon in youth sports. This effect exists when the relative age quarter distribution of selected athletes shows a biased distribution with an over-representation of relatively older athletes. In alpine ski racing, it exists in all age categories (national youth levels up to World Cup). Studies so far could demonstrate that selected ski racers are relatively older, taller and heavier. It could be hypothesized that relatively younger athletes nearly only have a chance for selection if they are early maturing. However, surprisingly this influence of the biological maturity status on the RAE could not be proven, yet. Therefore, the aim of the present study was to investigate the influence of the biological maturity status on the RAE in dependence of the level of competition. The study investigated 372 elite youth ski racers: 234 provincial ski racers (P-SR; high level of competition) and 137 national ski racers (N-SR; very high level of competition). Anthropometric characteristics were measured to calculate the age at peak height velocity (APHV) as an indicator of the biological maturity status. A significant RAE was present among both P-SR and N-SR, with a larger effect size among the latter group. The N-SR significantly differed in APHV from the P-SR. The distribution of normal, early and late maturing athletes significantly differed from the expected normal distribution among the N-SR, not among the P-SR. Hardly any late maturing N-SR were present; 41.7% of the male and 34% of the female N-SR of the last relative age quarter were early maturing. These findings clearly demonstrate the significant influence of the biological maturity status on the selection process of youth alpine ski racing in dependence of the level of competition. Relatively younger athletes seem to have a chance of selection only if they are early maturing.
相对年龄效应(RAE)是青少年体育运动中一个有充分文献记载的现象。当所选运动员的相对年龄四分位数分布呈现出偏差分布,相对年长的运动员比例过高时,这种效应就会存在。在高山滑雪比赛中,它存在于所有年龄组(从国家青年水平到世界杯)。迄今为止的研究表明,所选的滑雪运动员相对年龄更大、更高、更重。可以推测,相对年轻的运动员几乎只有在早熟的情况下才有机会被选中。然而,令人惊讶的是,生物成熟状态对相对年龄效应的这种影响尚未得到证实。因此,本研究的目的是探讨生物成熟状态对相对年龄效应的影响,并考察其与比赛水平的关系。该研究调查了372名精英青年滑雪运动员:234名省级滑雪运动员(P-SR;高水平比赛)和137名国家级滑雪运动员(N-SR;非常高水平比赛)。测量了人体测量特征,以计算身高速度峰值年龄(APHV),作为生物成熟状态的指标。P-SR和N-SR中均存在显著的相对年龄效应,后一组的效应量更大。N-SR的APHV与P-SR有显著差异。正常、早熟和晚熟运动员的分布在N-SR中与预期的正态分布有显著差异,而在P-SR中则没有。几乎没有晚熟的N-SR;在最后一个相对年龄四分位数中,41.7%的男性和34%的女性N-SR是早熟的。这些发现清楚地表明了生物成熟状态对青少年高山滑雪比赛选拔过程的显著影响,并考察其与比赛水平的关系。相对年轻的运动员似乎只有在早熟的情况下才有机会被选中。