Pignatelli Isabella, Kumar Aditya, Shah Kumar, Balonis Magdalena, Bauchy Mathieu, Wu Benjamin, Sant Gaurav
Laboratory for the Chemistry of Construction Materials (LC(2)), Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, University of California, Los Angeles, CA 90095, USA.
Division of Advanced Prosthodontics, School of Dentistry, University of California Los Angeles, CA 90095, USA.
Dent Mater. 2016 Oct;32(10):e251-e261. doi: 10.1016/j.dental.2016.07.004. Epub 2016 Aug 9.
Remineralization and demineralization are processes that compete in the oral environment. At this time, numerous therapeutic agents are being developed to promote remineralization (precipitation) or suppress demineralization (dissolution). To evaluate the relative efficacy of such treatments, there is a need for non-invasive, real-time, high-resolution quantifications of topographical changes occurring during demineralization and remineralization.
Vertical scanning interferometry (VSI) is demonstrated to be a quantitative method to assess reactions, and topographical changes occurring on enamel surfaces following exposure to demineralizing, and remineralizing liquids.
First, the dissolution rate of enamel was compared to that of synthetic hydroxyapatite (HAP) under acidic conditions (pH=4). Second, VSI was used to compare the remineralization effects of F(-)-based and CCP-ACP agents. The former produced a remineralization rate of ≈349nm/h, similar to simulated body fluid (SBF; concentration 4.6×) while the latter produced a remineralization rate of ≈55nm/h, corresponding to 1.7× SBF. However, the precipitates formed by the CCP-ACP agent are found to demineralize 2.7× slower than that produced by its F(-)-counterpart.
Based on this new VSI-based data, a remineralization factor (RF) and demineralization (DF) factor benchmarked, respectively, to 1× SBF and the demineralization rate of human enamel are suggested as figures of merit of therapeutic performance of dental treatments. Taken together, the outcomes offer new insights that can inform clinicians and researchers on the selection of remineralization strategies.
再矿化和脱矿化是口腔环境中相互竞争的过程。目前,正在研发多种治疗剂以促进再矿化(沉淀)或抑制脱矿化(溶解)。为评估此类治疗的相对疗效,需要对脱矿化和再矿化过程中发生的表面形貌变化进行非侵入性、实时、高分辨率定量分析。
垂直扫描干涉测量法(VSI)被证明是一种定量评估暴露于脱矿化液和再矿化液后牙釉质表面发生的反应及表面形貌变化的方法。
首先,比较了牙釉质在酸性条件(pH = 4)下与合成羟基磷灰石(HAP)的溶解速率。其次,使用VSI比较了基于氟(F⁻)和酪蛋白磷酸肽-无定形磷酸钙(CCP-ACP)制剂的再矿化效果。前者产生的再矿化速率约为349nm/h,与模拟体液(SBF;浓度4.6×)相似,而后者产生的再矿化速率约为55nm/h,相当于1.7× SBF。然而,发现CCP-ACP制剂形成的沉淀物脱矿化速度比其对应的F⁻制剂慢2.7倍。
基于这些新的VSI数据,建议分别以1× SBF和人牙釉质脱矿化速率为基准的再矿化因子(RF)和脱矿化因子(DF)作为牙科治疗疗效的评价指标。总之,这些结果提供了新的见解,可为临床医生和研究人员选择再矿化策略提供参考。