Gils Charlotte, Pottegård Anton, Ennis Zandra Nymand, Damkier Per
Department of Clinical Biochemistry & Pharmacology, Odense University Hospital, Odense, Denmark.
Clinical Pharmacology and Pharmaceutics, Department of Public Health, University of Southern Denmark, Odense, Denmark.
BMC Pregnancy Childbirth. 2016 Aug 17;16:226. doi: 10.1186/s12884-016-1025-6.
Estimating the true risk of fetal malformations attributable to the use of medications is difficult and perception of risk by health professionals will impact their counseling and treatment of patients who need medication during pregnancy. The objective of this study was to assess the perception of the teratogenic risk of 9 commonly and 3 rarely prescribed drugs among general practitioners and specialists in obstetrics/gynecology.
All 811 general practitioners in the Region of Southern Denmark and all 502 specialist obstetricians/gynecologists in Denmark as a whole were invited to participate in the study based on an online questionnaire. Medians and interpercentile ranges of the perceived background risk and perceived risks for each of the drugs were included in the questionnaire.
One hundred forty three (18 %) general practitioners and 138 (27 %) obstetricians/gynecologists participated. Estimates provided by the participants were generally in accordance with current knowledge of drugs with established safety during pregnancy. Perceptions of risks associated with warfarin and retinoid exposure were severely underestimated.
Understanding of teratogenic background risk and specific risks associated with in utero exposure to 12 different drugs generally approached the established knowledge. The risk associated with warfarin and retinoid exposure was severely underestimated by both groups of health care professionals, while general practitioners specifically overestimated the risk of sertraline and citalopram to some extent. In Denmark, general practitioners can prescribe antidepressants, and even minor misconceptions of the teratogenic potential of citalopram and sertraline may be of clinical relevance. In Denmark, systemic retinoids can only be prescribed by a dermatologist, and warfarin treatment is only rarely initiated in women of the fertile age without involvement of specialists in internal medicine. Hence, the active knowledge on the teratogenic potential of these drugs is likely to be less accurate among general practitioners and obstetricians/gynecologists; although still of clinical importance since these specialists are largely involved in the counselling of pregnant women.
估计药物使用导致胎儿畸形的真实风险很困难,而医疗专业人员对风险的认知会影响他们对孕期需要用药的患者的咨询和治疗。本研究的目的是评估全科医生以及妇产科专科医生对9种常用和3种罕用处方药致畸风险的认知。
基于一份在线问卷,邀请了丹麦南部地区的所有811名全科医生以及丹麦全国所有502名妇产科专科医生参与研究。问卷中纳入了感知到的背景风险以及每种药物的感知风险的中位数和百分位数范围。
143名(18%)全科医生和138名(27%)妇产科专科医生参与了研究。参与者给出的估计通常与当前关于孕期安全药物的知识相符。与华法林和维甲酸暴露相关的风险认知被严重低估。
对致畸背景风险以及与子宫内暴露于12种不同药物相关的特定风险的理解总体上接近既定知识。两组医疗保健专业人员都严重低估了与华法林和维甲酸暴露相关的风险,而全科医生在一定程度上特别高估了舍曲林和西酞普兰的风险。在丹麦,全科医生可以开具抗抑郁药,即使对西酞普兰和舍曲林致畸潜力的轻微误解也可能具有临床相关性。在丹麦,系统性维甲酸只能由皮肤科医生开具,而在没有内科专家参与的情况下,育龄女性很少开始使用华法林治疗。因此,全科医生和妇产科专科医生对这些药物致畸潜力的实际了解可能不太准确;尽管由于这些专家在很大程度上参与孕妇咨询,其仍然具有临床重要性。