Pohl M, Bertram M
Helios Klinik Schloss Pulsnitz, Wittgensteiner Strasse 1, 01896, Pulsnitz, Deutschland.
Kliniken Schmieder, Heidelberg, Deutschland.
Nervenarzt. 2016 Oct;87(10):1043-1050. doi: 10.1007/s00115-016-0183-0.
Early neurological and neurosurgical rehabilitation (ENNR) as a complex post-acute form of treatment for patients with severe neurological diseases and continued need for intensive care is well established in Germany.
To assess the efficacy of ENNR from the perspective of evidence-based medicine as well as to present data on the outcome of ENNR patients including the analysis of prognostic factors.
A search was carried out in PubMed databases to identify early rehabilitation treatment forms evaluated by randomized controlled trials and with respect to large multicenter surveys of outcome and prognostic factors.
For ENNR as a complex treatment concept, effectiveness not has been shown with regard to evidence-based medicine but it includes individually effective treatment forms. In two large multicenter evaluations the average duration of treatment was between 51 and 57 days and mortality was between 6 % and 10 %, increasing with the proportion of mechanically ventilated patients. Lower need for nursing support on admission indicated better outcome, whereas mechanical ventilation was more likely to be associated with poor outcome. Long-term outcome was negatively influenced by mechanical ventilation as well as severe neurogenic dysphagia with and without the need for a tracheal cannula and/or percutaneous endoscopic gastrostomy (PEG) and also by severely impaired communication at the end of ENNR.
These prognostic factors indicate the primary aims of ENNR, which are to reduce the need for nursing support and to establish the capability for rehabilitation. If these aims are achieved, favorable functional and long-term outcome can be expected for ENNR patients. The presented studies verify the sustained efficacy of ENNR as an essential part of the overall treatment concept for severely neurologically impaired patients.
在德国,早期神经和神经外科康复(ENNR)作为一种针对患有严重神经系统疾病且仍需重症监护的患者的复杂急性后期治疗形式已得到广泛认可。
从循证医学的角度评估ENNR的疗效,并呈现ENNR患者的预后数据,包括对预后因素的分析。
在PubMed数据库中进行检索,以确定通过随机对照试验评估的早期康复治疗形式,以及关于结局和预后因素的大型多中心调查。
对于ENNR这种复杂的治疗概念,循证医学方面尚未显示出有效性,但它包含个别有效的治疗形式。在两项大型多中心评估中,平均治疗时长在51至57天之间,死亡率在6%至10%之间,且随着机械通气患者比例的增加而上升。入院时对护理支持的需求较低表明预后较好,而机械通气更可能与不良预后相关。机械通气以及伴有或不伴有气管插管和/或经皮内镜下胃造口术(PEG)的严重神经源性吞咽困难,以及ENNR结束时严重受损的沟通能力,均对长期预后产生负面影响。
这些预后因素表明了ENNR的主要目标,即减少对护理支持的需求并建立康复能力。如果实现了这些目标,ENNR患者有望获得良好的功能和长期预后。所呈现的研究证实了ENNR作为严重神经功能受损患者整体治疗概念重要组成部分的持续疗效。