Reznikov Natalie, Chase Hila, Ben Zvi Yehonatan, Tarle Victoria, Singer Matthew, Brumfeld Vlad, Shahar Ron, Weiner Steve
Department of Structural Biology, Weizmann Institute of Science, Rehovot, Israel; Imperial College London, London, UK.
Department of Structural Biology, Weizmann Institute of Science, Rehovot, Israel; Hunter College, City University of New York, NY, USA.
Acta Biomater. 2016 Oct 15;44:65-72. doi: 10.1016/j.actbio.2016.08.040. Epub 2016 Aug 21.
Trabecular bone is an intricate 3D network of struts and plates. Although the structure-function relations in trabecular bone have been studied since the time of Julius Wolff, controversy still exists regarding the architectural parameters responsible for its stability and resilience. We present a parameter that measures the angle between two connected trabeculae - the Inter-Trabecular Angle (ITA). We studied the ITA values derived from μCT scans of different regions of the proximal femora of 5 individuals of different age and sex. We show that the ITA angle distribution of nodes with 3 connecting trabeculae has a mean close to 120°, nodes with 4 connecting trabeculae has a mean close to 109° and nodes of higher connectivity have mean ITA values around 100°. This tendency to spread the ITAs around geometrically symmetrical motifs is highly conserved. The implication is that the ITAs are optimized such that the smallest amount of material spans the maximal 3D volume, and possibly by so doing trabecular bone might be better adapted to multidirectional loading. We also draw a parallel between trabecular bone and tensegrity structures - where lightweight, resilient and stable tetrahedron-based shapes contribute to strain redistribution amongst all the elements and to collective impact dampening.
The Inter-Trabecular Angle (ITA) is a new topological parameter of trabecular bone. The ITA characterizes the way trabeculae connect with each other at nodes, regardless of their thickness and shape. The mean ITA value of nodes with 3 trabeculae is close to 120°, of nodes with 4 trabeculae is just below 109°, and the mean ITA of nodes with 5 and more trabeculae is around 100°. Thus the connections of trabeculae trend towards adopting symmetrical shapes. This implies that trabeculae can maximally span 3D space using the minimal amount of material. We draw a parallel between this motif and the concept of tensegrity - an engineering premise to which many living creatures conform at multiple levels of organization.
小梁骨是由支柱和骨板构成的复杂三维网络。尽管自尤利乌斯·沃尔夫时代起就开始研究小梁骨的结构 - 功能关系,但对于决定其稳定性和弹性的结构参数仍存在争议。我们提出了一个测量两个相连小梁之间角度的参数——小梁间角度(ITA)。我们研究了来自5名不同年龄和性别的个体近端股骨不同区域的μCT扫描得出的ITA值。我们发现,具有3个相连小梁的节点的ITA角度分布均值接近120°,具有4个相连小梁的节点的均值接近109°,而具有更高连接性的节点的ITA均值约为100°。这种将ITA围绕几何对称图案分布的趋势高度保守。这意味着ITA经过优化,使得最少的材料能够跨越最大的三维体积,并且通过这样做,小梁骨可能更好地适应多向载荷。我们还将小梁骨与张拉整体结构进行了类比——在张拉整体结构中,基于轻质、有弹性且稳定的四面体形状有助于在所有元素之间进行应变重新分布以及集体减震。
小梁间角度(ITA)是小梁骨的一个新的拓扑参数。ITA表征了小梁在节点处相互连接的方式,而不考虑它们的厚度和形状。具有3个小梁的节点的ITA均值接近120°,具有4个小梁的节点的均值略低于109°,具有5个及更多小梁的节点的ITA均值约为100°。因此,小梁的连接倾向于采用对称形状。这意味着小梁可以用最少的材料最大程度地跨越三维空间。我们将这种图案与张拉整体概念进行了类比——张拉整体是一个工程前提,许多生物在多个组织层次上都符合这一前提。