Trochim William M
435 Kennedy Hall, Cornell University, Ithaca, NY 14853, United States(1)(2).
Eval Program Plann. 2017 Feb;60:176-185. doi: 10.1016/j.evalprogplan.2016.08.009. Epub 2016 Aug 28.
This paper considers the origins and development of the concept mapping methodology, a summary of its growth, and its influence in a variety of fields. From initial discussions with graduate students, through the rise of the theory-driven approach to program evaluation and the development of a theoretical framework for conceptualization methodology, the paper highlights some of the key early efforts and pilot projects that culminated in a 1989 special issue on the method in Evaluation and Program Planning that brought the method to the attention of the field of evaluation. The paper details the thinking that led to the standard version of the method (the analytic sequence, "bridging" index, and pattern matching) and the development of the software for accomplishing it. A bibliometric analysis shows that the rate of citation continues to increase, where it has grown geographically and institutionally, that the method has been used in a wide variety of disciplines and specialties, and that the literature had an influence on the field. The article concludes with a critical appraisal of some of the key aspects of the approach that warrant further development.
本文探讨了概念映射方法的起源与发展、其发展概况及其在各个领域的影响。从最初与研究生的讨论,到理论驱动的项目评估方法的兴起以及概念化方法理论框架的发展,本文重点介绍了一些关键的早期努力和试点项目,这些最终促成了1989年《评估与项目规划》关于该方法的特刊,使该方法受到评估领域的关注。本文详细阐述了形成该方法标准版本(分析序列、“桥梁”指标和模式匹配)的思路以及实现该方法的软件的开发。文献计量分析表明,该方法的被引率持续上升,其应用在地域和机构上不断扩展,已被广泛应用于各种学科和专业,且相关文献对该领域产生了影响。文章最后对该方法一些值得进一步发展的关键方面进行了批判性评价。