Xing Shufen, Zhou Quan, Archer Marc, Yue Jianhong, Wang Zhengyan
Psychological Department, School of Education Science, Capital Normal University, Beijing, China.
Institute of Psychology, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing, China.
Early Hum Dev. 2016 Oct;101:99-105. doi: 10.1016/j.earlhumdev.2016.08.014. Epub 2016 Sep 8.
The differential susceptibility hypothesis suggests that children's innate characteristics and their rearing experiences interact differentially during development. Recently, the study of interactions between infants' temperament and rearing experiences has become a research hotspot. In China, grandparental care is a very common phenomenon, with many infants taken care of by grandparents while mothers are out for work.
To investigate whether the associations between maternal and grandmaternal sensitivity, and behavior problems were moderated by infant temperamental reactivity, while the infants were raised by both their mothers and grandmothers.
A total of 71 infants (average age of 17.6months), their mothers and grandmothers were included in this study.
Maternal sensitivity and grandmaternal sensitivity were assessed with the Maternal Behavior Q-sort-Chinese Version, infants' temperamental reactivity was measured with Carey's Toddler Temperament Questionnaire-Chinese Revision, and infants' behavior problems were measured with the Infant-Toddler Social and Emotional Assessment-Chinese Version.
Maternal sensitivity significantly predicted infants' impulsivity and aggression. Infants' temperamental reactivity moderated the effect of maternal sensitivity on infants' general anxiety. In addition, infant temperamental reactivity moderated the impact of grandmaternal sensitivity on infants' separation distress.
Our results support the differential susceptibility hypothesis to some extent. Infants with high temperamental reactivity not only suffer more from low maternal and grandmaternal sensitivity, but also benefit more from high maternal and grandmaternal sensitivity as compared to those infants with low temperamental reactivity.
差异易感性假说认为,儿童的先天特征与其养育经历在发育过程中存在不同的相互作用。最近,婴儿气质与养育经历之间的相互作用研究已成为一个研究热点。在中国,祖辈照料是一种非常普遍的现象,许多婴儿在母亲外出工作时由祖父母照料。
探讨在婴儿由母亲和祖母共同抚养的情况下,婴儿气质反应性是否会调节母亲和祖母的敏感性与行为问题之间的关联。
本研究共纳入71名婴儿(平均年龄17.6个月)及其母亲和祖母。
采用中文版母亲行为Q分类法评估母亲敏感性和祖母敏感性,采用中文版凯里幼儿气质问卷测量婴儿的气质反应性,采用中文版婴幼儿社会和情感评估量表测量婴儿的行为问题。
母亲敏感性显著预测婴儿的冲动性和攻击性。婴儿的气质反应性调节了母亲敏感性对婴儿一般焦虑的影响。此外,婴儿气质反应性调节了祖母敏感性对婴儿分离焦虑的影响。
我们的结果在一定程度上支持差异易感性假说。与气质反应性低的婴儿相比,气质反应性高的婴儿不仅在母亲和祖母敏感性低时受影响更大,而且在母亲和祖母敏感性高时受益也更多。