Hinds Richard M, Klifto Christopher S, Naik Amish A, Sapienza Anthony, Capo John T
Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, New York University Hospital for Joint Diseases, New York, United States.
J Hand Microsurg. 2016 Aug;8(2):91-5. doi: 10.1055/s-0036-1583551. Epub 2016 Apr 28.
The Internet is a common resource for applicants of hand surgery fellowships, however, the quality and accessibility of fellowship online information is unknown. The objectives of this study were to evaluate the accessibility of hand surgery fellowship Web sites and to assess the quality of information provided via program Web sites. Hand fellowship Web site accessibility was evaluated by reviewing the American Society for Surgery of the Hand (ASSH) on November 16, 2014 and the National Resident Matching Program (NRMP) fellowship directories on February 12, 2015, and performing an independent Google search on November 25, 2014. Accessible Web sites were then assessed for quality of the presented information. A total of 81 programs were identified with the ASSH directory featuring direct links to 32% of program Web sites and the NRMP directory directly linking to 0%. A Google search yielded direct links to 86% of program Web sites. The quality of presented information varied greatly among the 72 accessible Web sites. Program description (100%), fellowship application requirements (97%), program contact email address (85%), and research requirements (75%) were the most commonly presented components of fellowship information. Hand fellowship program Web sites can be accessed from the ASSH directory and, to a lesser extent, the NRMP directory. However, a Google search is the most reliable method to access online fellowship information. Of assessable programs, all featured a program description though the quality of the remaining information was variable. Hand surgery fellowship applicants may face some difficulties when attempting to gather program information online. Future efforts should focus on improving the accessibility and content quality on hand surgery fellowship program Web sites.
互联网是手外科专科医师培训申请者的常用资源,然而,专科医师培训在线信息的质量和可获取性尚不清楚。本研究的目的是评估手外科专科医师培训网站的可获取性,并评估通过项目网站提供的信息质量。通过在2014年11月16日查阅美国手外科医师学会(ASSH)以及在2015年2月12日查阅全国住院医师匹配计划(NRMP)专科医师培训名录,并于2014年11月25日进行独立的谷歌搜索,对手外科专科医师培训网站的可获取性进行了评估。然后对可访问的网站进行了所呈现信息质量的评估。共识别出81个项目,ASSH名录中有直接链接至32%的项目网站,而NRMP名录中直接链接的比例为0%。谷歌搜索产生了86%的项目网站的直接链接。在72个可访问的网站中,所呈现信息的质量差异很大。项目描述(100%)、专科医师培训申请要求(97%)、项目联系电子邮件地址(85%)和研究要求(75%)是专科医师培训信息中最常呈现 的组成部分。手外科专科医师培训项目网站可从ASSH名录中访问,在较小程度上也可从NRMP名录中访问。然而,谷歌搜索是获取在线专科医师培训信息最可靠的方法。在所评估的项目中,所有项目都有项目描述,不过其余信息的质量参差不齐。手外科专科医师培训申请者在试图在线收集项目信息时可能会面临一些困难。未来的努力应集中在提高手外科专科医师培训项目网站的可获取性和内容质量上。