Jaensson Maria, Nilsson Ulrica
School of Health Sciences, Faculty of Medicine and Health, Örebro University, Örebro, Sweden.
J Eval Clin Pract. 2017 Jun;23(3):502-507. doi: 10.1111/jep.12639. Epub 2016 Sep 21.
RATIONALE, AIMS, AND OBJECTIVES: The Swedish web-version of the Quality of Recovery questionnaire is used to evaluate a person's postoperative recovery after anesthesia and surgery. An earlier study found an increased risk of answering incorrectly when the questionnaire included both positive and negative items. Therefore, this study investigated the effect of changing positively worded items to negatively worded items.
This was a cross-sectional study including 90 second-year nursing students. Seven pairs of positively and negatively worded items were evaluated for differences in response as well as agreement between the items.
Two pairs of items showed higher mean values if the item was negatively worded. Between-item agreement for positively worded item scores and their corresponding reverse-coded negatively worded item scores was poor-to-moderate (intraclass correlation coefficient: 0.35-0.76). A moderate agreement was found when testing all positively worded items against the recoded negatively worded items (intraclass correlation coefficient: 0.65). Internal consistency was 0.86 for the positively worded items and 0.76 for the negatively worded items.
Changing from positive to negative wording produced some differences in Swedish web-version of the Quality of Recovery item scores. Internal consistency was acceptable, but 2 items (not having a general feeling of well-being and not speaking normally) need further refinement.
原理、目的和目标:瑞典版的术后恢复质量问卷网络版用于评估个体在麻醉和手术后的恢复情况。一项早期研究发现,当问卷同时包含正向和负向项目时,回答错误的风险会增加。因此,本研究调查了将正向表述的项目改为负向表述的项目所产生的影响。
这是一项横断面研究,纳入了90名护理专业二年级学生。对七对正向和负向表述的项目进行了反应差异以及项目间一致性的评估。
两对项目在负向表述时显示出更高的均值。正向表述项目得分与其相应的反向编码负向表述项目得分之间的项目间一致性较差至中等(组内相关系数:0.35 - 0.76)。在将所有正向表述项目与重新编码的负向表述项目进行测试时,发现一致性中等(组内相关系数:0.65)。正向表述项目的内部一致性为0.86,负向表述项目的内部一致性为0.76。
从正向表述改为负向表述在瑞典版术后恢复质量项目得分上产生了一些差异。内部一致性是可接受的,但有2个项目(没有总体幸福感和说话不正常)需要进一步完善。