Granleese J, Turner I, Trew K
Br J Educ Psychol. 1989 Feb;59 ( Pt 1):31-7. doi: 10.1111/j.2044-8279.1989.tb03073.x.
Research into the role of teachers in maintaining self-concepts which reflect gender stereotypes has been hampered by the lack of parallel multidimensional instruments. The development of the Teachers' Rating Scale of the Child's Competence (TRSCC) and the Perceived Competence Scale for Children (PCSC) (Harter, 1982) answers this problem. Thirty-six boys and 38 girls of mean ages 10 years 8 months (SD = 3.6 months) and 10 years 9 months (SD = 3.3 months) respectively completed the PCSC while their teachers (N = 12) completed the TRSCC. It was found that: (1) teachers' mean ratings of boys' competence did not significantly differ from their ratings of girls' competence; (2) teachers' ratings demonstrated significant differences between boys and girls in the pattern of interrelationships of the domains of competence; (3) teachers' perceptions and pupils' self-perceptions in the patterns of interrelationships amongst the domains of competence showed similar patterns for teachers and boys, and almost similar patterns for teachers and girls; (4) teachers were more important for girls' self-perceived competence than for boys' self-perceived competence; (5) both teachers and pupils use perceived physical competence as a construct associated with significantly differentiating between boys and girls in other domains of competence. These findings have pedagogical implications for the treatment of girls.
由于缺乏平行的多维工具,关于教师在维持反映性别刻板印象的自我概念方面所起作用的研究受到了阻碍。儿童能力教师评定量表(TRSCC)和儿童感知能力量表(PCSC)(哈特,1982年)的开发解决了这个问题。36名男孩和38名女孩分别完成了PCSC,他们的平均年龄为10岁8个月(标准差 = 3.6个月)和10岁9个月(标准差 = 3.3个月),而他们的教师(N = 12)完成了TRSCC。研究发现:(1)教师对男孩能力的平均评分与对女孩能力的评分没有显著差异;(2)教师的评分在能力领域的相互关系模式上显示出男孩和女孩之间的显著差异;(3)教师在能力领域之间的相互关系模式中的看法与学生的自我认知在教师与男孩之间呈现出相似的模式,在教师与女孩之间呈现出几乎相似的模式;(4)教师对女孩自我感知能力的影响比对男孩自我感知能力的影响更大;(5)教师和学生都将感知到的身体能力作为一种结构,这种结构与在其他能力领域中显著区分男孩和女孩有关。这些发现对女孩的教育具有启示意义。