McCay Elizabeth, Carter Celina, Aiello Andria, Quesnel Susan, Howes Carol, Johansson Bjorn
Daphne Cockwell School of Nursing, Ryerson University, Toronto ON, Canada.
Centre for Addiction and Mental Health, Toronto ON, Canada.
Arch Psychiatr Nurs. 2016 Oct;30(5):568-74. doi: 10.1016/j.apnu.2016.04.001. Epub 2016 Apr 6.
The current paper discusses an approach to measuring treatment integrity of dialectical behavioral therapy (DBT) when implemented within two programs providing services to street-involved youth in the community. Measuring treatment integrity is a critical component of effective implementation of evidence-based interventions in clinical practice, since sound treatment integrity increases confidence in client outcomes and intervention replicability. Despite being an essential part of implementation science, few studies report on treatment integrity, with limited research addressing either measurement tools or maintenance of treatment integrity. To address the lack of available treatment integrity measures, researchers in the current study developed and piloted a treatment integrity measure which pertain to the individual and group components of DBT. A total of 20 recordings were assessed using the treatment integrity measure. Results indicate that the community agency staff (e.g. youth workers, social workers & nurses) implemented the intervention as intended; increasing confidence in the outcome variables, the staffs' training and the replicability of the intervention. This article offers one approach to addressing treatment integrity when implementing evidence-based interventions, such as DBT in a community setting, and discusses the need for effective and feasible integrity measures that can be adopted in order to strengthen mental health practice in community settings.
本文讨论了一种在两个为社区中与街头有联系的青少年提供服务的项目中实施辩证行为疗法(DBT)时测量治疗完整性的方法。测量治疗完整性是临床实践中有效实施循证干预措施的关键组成部分,因为可靠的治疗完整性会增强对客户治疗结果和干预可重复性的信心。尽管治疗完整性是实施科学的重要组成部分,但很少有研究报告治疗完整性情况,涉及测量工具或治疗完整性维持的研究有限。为了解决可用治疗完整性测量方法的缺乏问题,本研究的研究人员开发并试用了一种与DBT的个体和团体组成部分相关的治疗完整性测量方法。使用该治疗完整性测量方法对总共20次记录进行了评估。结果表明,社区机构工作人员(如青少年工作者、社会工作者和护士)按预期实施了干预;这增强了对结果变量、工作人员培训和干预可重复性的信心。本文提供了一种在社区环境中实施循证干预措施(如DBT)时解决治疗完整性问题的方法,并讨论了为加强社区环境中的心理健康实践而采用有效且可行的完整性测量方法的必要性。