Antommaria Armand H Matheny
Cincinnati Children's Hospital Medical Center, 3333 Burnet Avenue, ML 15006, Cincinnati, Ohio 45229 USA.
J Clin Ethics. 2016 Fall;27(3):248-250.
Conscience can influence physicians' interactions with patients in myriad ways and, by extension, can influence the interactions and internal dynamics of a health care team. The AMA's opinion around physicians' exercise of conscience appropriately balance the obligations physicians have to their patients and profession, and the rights of physicians as moral agents to exercise their conscience. While the opinion is an effective starting point, further guidance is necessary to clarify the process by which physicians should identify, manage, and, if necessary, report their conscientious refusals to patients, supervisors, or colleagues. In addition to laying out a proposed process for identifying and managing issues of conscience, this article will use relevant and timely examples to help clarify how a physician could apply this process in an instance of conscientious refusal.
良知能够以多种方式影响医生与患者的互动,进而影响医疗团队的互动及内部动态。美国医学协会(AMA)关于医生良知行使的意见恰当地平衡了医生对患者和职业所负有的义务,以及医生作为道德主体行使良知的权利。虽然该意见是一个有效的起点,但仍需要进一步的指导,以阐明医生应如何识别、管理以及在必要时向患者、上级或同事报告其出于良知的拒绝。除了提出一个识别和管理良知问题的建议流程外,本文还将使用相关且适时的示例,以帮助阐明医生在出于良知拒绝的情况下如何应用这一流程。