Garty I, Friedman A, Sandler M P, Kedar A
Department of Nuclear Medicine, Central Emek Hospital, Afula, Israel.
Clin Nucl Med. 1989 Jul;14(7):515-22. doi: 10.1097/00003072-198907000-00009.
Fourteen children with histopathologically confirmed neuroblastoma underwent sequential correlative imaging studies using I-131 MIBG, Tc-99m MDP, and Ga-67 citrate during various stages of the disease. Of the patients 86% showed I-131 MIBG accumulation in the primary tumoral site, whereas 71% showed Tc-99m MDP and 79% Ga-67 citrate uptake. In 86% at least one of the two latter radiopharmaceuticals concentrated in the primary tumor. The use of all three radiopharmaceuticals raised the detection rate to 93%. Of the osseous or extraosseous metastases 100% were detected by Tc-99m MDP studies. The I-131 MIBG studies were positive in 71% of the osseous metastases and in 70% of the extraosseous metastases. No Ga-67 citrate uptake was demonstrated in osseous metastases, although one extraosseous lung metastasis concentrated this radiopharmaceutical. Tc-99m MDP bone imaging was the best method for diagnosing metastatic spread of the disease and for monitoring the results of treatment. Primary tumor uptake was best indicated by I-131 MIBG. Both Ga-67 citrate and I-131 MIBG were superior to Tc-99m MDP with regard to accurately demonstrating the extent of primary tumors. Only Tc-99m MDP indicated the relationship of these tumors to the kidneys and neighboring osseous structures, providing early screening of kidney compression. Ga-67 citrate study was mainly indicated in tumors with catecholamine depletion, which failed to concentrate the other two radiopharmaceuticals. I-131 MIBG proved especially useful in detecting neuroblastoma with negative Tc-99m MDP and Ga-67 citrate studies and also proved to be helpful with those cases in which I-131 MIBG was planned for therapy. The following strategy is suggested for evaluating neuroblastoma.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
14名经组织病理学确诊为神经母细胞瘤的儿童在疾病的不同阶段接受了I-131 MIBG、Tc-99m MDP和Ga-67柠檬酸盐的系列相关成像研究。86%的患者在原发肿瘤部位显示I-131 MIBG摄取,而71%显示Tc-99m MDP摄取,79%显示Ga-67柠檬酸盐摄取。86%的患者后两种放射性药物中至少有一种在原发肿瘤中浓聚。使用所有三种放射性药物将检出率提高到93%。Tc-99m MDP研究检测出100%的骨转移或骨外转移。I-131 MIBG研究在71%的骨转移和70%的骨外转移中呈阳性。骨转移中未显示Ga-67柠檬酸盐摄取,尽管有一处骨外肺转移浓聚了这种放射性药物。Tc-99m MDP骨显像对于诊断疾病的转移扩散和监测治疗结果是最佳方法。I-131 MIBG最能显示原发肿瘤摄取情况。就准确显示原发肿瘤范围而言,Ga-67柠檬酸盐和I-131 MIBG均优于Tc-99m MDP。只有Tc-99m MDP能显示这些肿瘤与肾脏及邻近骨结构的关系,有助于早期筛查肾脏受压情况。Ga-67柠檬酸盐研究主要适用于儿茶酚胺耗竭的肿瘤,这类肿瘤不能浓聚其他两种放射性药物。I-131 MIBG在Tc-99m MDP和Ga-67柠檬酸盐研究为阴性的神经母细胞瘤检测中特别有用,对于计划用I-131 MIBG治疗的病例也有帮助。建议采用以下策略评估神经母细胞瘤。(摘要截短于250字)