Landisch Rachel M, Colwell Ryan C, Densmore John C
Children's Research Institute and Children's Hospital of Wisconsin, Milwaukee, WI 53226; Medical College of Wisconsin, Milwaukee, WI 53226.
Children's Research Institute and Children's Hospital of Wisconsin, Milwaukee, WI 53226.
J Pediatr Surg. 2016 Dec;51(12):1976-1982. doi: 10.1016/j.jpedsurg.2016.09.025. Epub 2016 Sep 15.
Comparative outcomes of enhanced percutaneous endoscopic gastrostomy (PEG) and laparoscopic gastrostomy (LG) have not been elucidated in infants. We describe the outcomes and procedural episodic expenditures of PEG versus LG in this high-risk population.
One hundred eighty-three gastrostomies in children under 1year were reviewed from our institution spanning 1/2011-6/2015. Pertinent demographics and 3-month complications (mortality, gastrocolic fistula, reoperation, cellulitis, granulation, pneumonia, and tube dislodgement <6weeks) were collected. Facility and professional administrative data was used to conduct a charge and cost analysis of PEG and LG procedures as well as their statistically significant complications.
Seventy-eight PEG and 105 LG infants were compared. LG infants were significantly younger, had higher ASA class, and increased frequency of cardiopulmonary disease. Significant major complications included a 3.8% incidence of gastrocolic fistula among PEGs (3.8% vs 0%, p=0.04) and 7.6% early tube dislodgements among LG infants (0 vs. 7.6%, p=0.01), resulting in $86,896 of additional charges with PEG complication. Incorporating complication frequency, average charges and variable cost per case were $8964 and $253 greater using PEG.
Despite a healthier cohort, infants undergoing enhanced PEG have more morbid and costly complications. LG may be the less burdensome approach to gastrostomy in infants.
Case-Control Study/Retrospective Comparative Study - Level III.
婴儿中增强经皮内镜胃造口术(PEG)和腹腔镜胃造口术(LG)的比较结果尚未阐明。我们描述了高危人群中PEG与LG的结果及手术期间的支出情况。
回顾了2011年1月至2015年6月我院183例1岁以下儿童的胃造口术。收集相关人口统计学资料及3个月时的并发症(死亡率、胃结肠瘘、再次手术、蜂窝织炎、肉芽组织、肺炎及6周内的管道移位)。利用机构和专业管理数据对PEG和LG手术及其具有统计学意义的并发症进行收费和成本分析。
比较了78例接受PEG和105例接受LG的婴儿。接受LG的婴儿明显更年幼,ASA分级更高,心肺疾病发生率更高。显著的主要并发症包括PEG组中胃结肠瘘发生率为3.8%(3.8%对0%,p = 0.04),LG组婴儿早期管道移位发生率为7.6%(0对7.6%,p = 0.01),PEG并发症导致额外收费86,896美元。考虑并发症发生率,PEG的平均收费和每例可变成本分别为8964美元和253美元更高。
尽管接受增强PEG的婴儿队列健康状况较好,但有更多严重且成本更高的并发症。LG可能是婴儿胃造口术负担较小的方法。
病例对照研究/回顾性比较研究 - 三级。