Gratrix Lesley, Barrett David
Faculty of Health and Social Care, University of Hull, Cottingham Road, Hull HU6 7RX, United Kingdom..
Nurse Educ Today. 2017 Jan;48:7-12. doi: 10.1016/j.nedt.2016.09.005. Epub 2016 Sep 16.
Academic supervision - the support available to students when writing assignments - is a fundamental element in the provision of support within nurse education. Not only can it underpin high levels of academic achievement, but it also has a role in enhancing the retention of students. Despite its importance, there is little investigation of undergraduate academic supervision within the nursing literature.
To explore students' experiences and expectations of academic supervision as part of an undergraduate programme of nurse education.
A qualitative approach to explore student perceptions.
The research was undertaken at a Higher Education Institution in the United Kingdom. The institution offers undergraduate nurse education programmes to approximately 800 students.
Eight pre-registration nursing students from a Bachelor of Science programme participated in a focus group interview. All were in the first semester of their final year.
Data were collected using focus group interviewing, based around a semistructured question framework. The focus groups explored students' expectations and previous experiences of academic supervision. The focus group was recorded, responses were transcribed and thematic analysis was undertaken to identify key findings.
Three themes were identified from the data: relationship with supervisor, variation between supervisors, and the link between supervision and marking. Overall, students identified frustration with variability in the provision of academic supervision.
Effective academic supervision depends on a strong relationship between student and supervisor - something that can be difficult to achieve if supervision is only for a short period of time. Equally, students crave a consistent approach to supervision, in terms of both the amount and content of feedback. Students are able to identify and articulate a clear link between effective supervision and academic achievement.
学业指导——学生在撰写作业时可获得的支持——是护理教育提供支持的基本要素。它不仅可以支撑高水平的学业成绩,还在提高学生留存率方面发挥作用。尽管其很重要,但护理文献中对本科阶段学业指导的研究却很少。
探讨作为本科护理教育项目一部分的学业指导中学生的经历和期望。
采用定性方法来探究学生的看法。
该研究在英国一所高等教育机构开展。该机构为大约800名学生提供本科护理教育项目。
来自理学学士项目的8名预注册护理专业学生参加了焦点小组访谈。他们均处于最后一年的第一学期。
基于半结构化问题框架,通过焦点小组访谈收集数据。焦点小组探讨了学生对学业指导的期望和以往经历。焦点小组访谈进行了录音,对回答进行了转录,并开展了主题分析以确定关键发现。
从数据中识别出三个主题:与导师的关系、导师之间的差异以及指导与评分之间的联系。总体而言,学生们指出对学业指导提供的不一致感到沮丧。
有效的学业指导依赖于学生与导师之间的紧密关系——如果指导时间很短,这可能难以实现。同样,学生渴望在反馈的数量和内容方面都有一致的指导方法。学生能够识别并清晰阐述有效指导与学业成绩之间的明确联系。