Nicholas Michael K, Asghari Ali, Blyth Fiona M, Wood Bradley M, Murray Robin, McCabe Rebecca, Brnabic Alan, Beeston Lee, Corbett Mandy, Sherrington Catherine, Overton Sarah
Pain Management Research Institute, University of Sydney at Royal North Shore Hospital, Sydney, Australia.
School of Psychology, Shahed University, Tehran, Iran.
Pain. 2017 Jan;158(1):86-95. doi: 10.1097/j.pain.0000000000000729.
This study compares the outcomes, from pretreatment to 1-year follow-up, of an outpatient, CBT-based pain self-management program (PSM) that included exercises, pain education, and pain coping strategies, with a control condition (exercise-attention control, EAC) that included exercises and a control for the attention of the treatment team. We previously reported short-term results (to 1-month follow-up) from the same study. This new paper considers the important issue of maintenance of treatment-related gains. The participants (n = 141) were a heterogeneous sample of ambulant, community-dwelling older adult patients with chronic pain (mean age: 73.90 [6.5] years [range: 65-87 years]). The long-term results indicate the pain self-management program group achieved and maintained significantly better results than the exercise-attention control group on the primary outcome, pain-related disability, as well as on usual pain, pain distress, depression, and fear-avoidance beliefs. The mean effect size for these gains by the pain self-management program group over the exercise-attention control group was 0.37 (range: 0.29-0.45), which is in the small effect size range. While statistically and clinically meaningful, these findings do indicate some weakening in effects over time but not to a significant degree. The study has implications for the provision of pain management interventions for community-dwelling older adults with chronic pain.
本研究比较了一种基于认知行为疗法(CBT)的门诊疼痛自我管理项目(PSM)从预处理到1年随访的结果,该项目包括锻炼、疼痛教育和疼痛应对策略,与一个对照条件(运动-注意力控制,EAC)进行比较,后者包括锻炼以及对治疗团队注意力的控制。我们之前报告了同一研究的短期结果(至1个月随访)。这篇新论文探讨了治疗相关收益维持的重要问题。参与者(n = 141)是一组来自社区、行动自如的慢性疼痛老年患者的异质性样本(平均年龄:73.90 [6.5]岁[范围:65 - 87岁])。长期结果表明,在主要结局指标疼痛相关残疾以及日常疼痛、疼痛困扰、抑郁和恐惧回避信念方面,疼痛自我管理项目组取得并维持了显著优于运动-注意力控制组的结果。疼痛自我管理项目组相对于运动-注意力控制组这些收益的平均效应大小为0.37(范围:0.29 - 0.45),属于小效应大小范围。虽然在统计学和临床上有意义,但这些发现确实表明随着时间推移效应有所减弱,但程度不显著。该研究对为社区居住的慢性疼痛老年人提供疼痛管理干预具有启示意义。