Jacobs W, Das E, Schagen S B
a Department of Communication and Information Science (CIW), Centre for Language Studies , Radboud University Nijmegen , Nijmegen , The Netherlands.
b Division of Psychosocial Research and Epidemiology , Netherlands Cancer Institute , Amsterdam , The Netherlands.
Psychol Health. 2017 Jan;32(1):78-93. doi: 10.1080/08870446.2016.1244535. Epub 2016 Nov 2.
Information about treatment side effects can increase their occurrence; breast cancer (BC) patients showed increased cognitive problem reporting (CPR) and decreased memory performance after information about cognitive side effects. The current study extends previous research on adverse information effects (AIE) by investigating (a) risk factors, (b) underlying mechanisms and (c) an intervention to reduce AIE.
In an online experiment, 175 female BC patients were randomly assigned to one of three conditions. In the two experimental groups, patients were informed about the possible occurrence of cognitive problems after chemotherapy with (intervention group) or without (experimental group) reassuring information that 'there are still patients who score well on memory tests'. In the control group, no reference to chemotherapy-related cognitive problems was made.
Main dependent measure was CPR. Four moderating and five mediating processes were examined.
CPR increased with higher levels of stigma consciousness in the two experimental groups, but not in the no-information control group.
Merely informing patients about cognitive side effects may increase their occurrence, especially among individuals vulnerable to patient stereotypes. Adding reassuring information is not sufficient to reduce AIE.
关于治疗副作用的信息可能会增加其发生率;乳腺癌(BC)患者在得知认知副作用的信息后,认知问题报告(CPR)增加,记忆表现下降。本研究通过调查(a)风险因素、(b)潜在机制和(c)一种减少不良信息效应(AIE)的干预措施,扩展了先前关于不良信息效应的研究。
在一项在线实验中,175名女性BC患者被随机分配到三种条件之一。在两个实验组中,患者被告知化疗后可能出现认知问题,其中干预组还收到了“仍有患者在记忆测试中得分良好”的安慰信息,而实验组则没有。在对照组中,未提及与化疗相关的认知问题。
主要的因变量是CPR。研究了四个调节过程和五个中介过程。
在两个实验组中,CPR随着污名意识水平的提高而增加,但在无信息对照组中没有增加。
仅仅告知患者认知副作用可能会增加其发生率,尤其是在易受患者刻板印象影响的个体中。添加安慰信息不足以减少AIE。