Keyser R E, Mor D, Andres F F
Division of Cardiovascular Services, Butterworth Hospital, Grand Rapids, MI 49503.
Arch Phys Med Rehabil. 1989 Sep;70(9):687-91.
Cardiovascular responses occurring at the anaerobic threshold (AT) were compared during intermittent bicycle and arm ergometry in eight healthy college students. Arm and bicycle tests used time-matched, discontinuous protocols (three-minute work stages alternated with three-minute rest intervals). Anaerobic threshold was determined by plotting expired minute volume (Ve) on oxygen consumption (VO2) and expressed as the percentage of the respective peak VO2 at which the deflection occurred. Analysis of variance revealed AT was similar for arm and bicycle tests. Absolute VO2 at AT was higher for bicycle than for arm ergometer exercise (p less than .05). Heart rate (HR) and rate pressure product (RPP) were higher for bicycle than for arm ergometry at AT (p less than .05). Moreover, a similarity in percent maximum RPP and percent maximum VO2 was observed at AT for arm ergometry, whereas percent maximum RPP was higher than percent maximum VO2 at AT for bicycle ergometry. Because AT has been suggested as an appropriate intensity of exercise for conditioning, it was concluded that a sufficient level of exercise intensity can be elicited at a lower percentage of the cardiovascular reserve for arm than for bicycle ergometer exercise.
在八名健康大学生中,对间歇式自行车运动和手臂测力计运动时无氧阈(AT)出现的心血管反应进行了比较。手臂和自行车测试采用时间匹配的间断方案(三分钟的工作阶段与三分钟的休息间隔交替进行)。通过将呼出分钟通气量(Ve)与耗氧量(VO2)绘制成图来确定无氧阈,并表示为出现偏移时各自峰值VO2的百分比。方差分析显示,手臂和自行车测试的无氧阈相似。自行车运动时无氧阈的绝对VO2高于手臂测力计运动(p小于0.05)。无氧阈时,自行车运动的心率(HR)和心率血压乘积(RPP)高于手臂测力计运动(p小于0.05)。此外,在无氧阈时,手臂测力计运动的最大RPP百分比和最大VO2百分比相似,而自行车测力计运动在无氧阈时的最大RPP百分比高于最大VO2百分比。由于无氧阈被认为是进行体能训练的合适运动强度,因此得出结论,与自行车测力计运动相比,手臂运动在较低的心血管储备百分比下就能引发足够的运动强度水平。