Shukla Garima, Gupta Anupama, Agarwal Priya, Poornima Shivani
Department of Neurology, All India Institute of Medical Sciences, New Delhi, India.
Department of Neurology, All India Institute of Medical Sciences, New Delhi, India.
Epilepsy Behav. 2016 Nov;64(Pt A):216-218. doi: 10.1016/j.yebeh.2016.08.005. Epub 2016 Oct 15.
Levetiracetam (LEV) is often chosen early in the treatment of refractory epilepsy; however, its adverse effects have largely been studied as part of clinical trials. Oxcarbazepine and valproate (VPA) are the other commonly used AEDs and, hence, serve as good comparators. This study was conducted to evaluate behavioral abnormalities and somnolence among patients with epilepsy being treated with LEV and/or OXC compared with those receiving VPA.
Data of consecutive patients attending our intractable epilepsy clinic over a 2 1/2-year period were reviewed, and patients with at least one seizure a month, who had been initiated on either or a combination of LEV, VPA, or OXC, were included for analysis. Data regarding behavioral adverse effects, daytime somnolence (EDS), and weight changes were collected apart from those regarding any major effect necessitating dose reduction or discontinuation of the AED.
Among a total of 445 patients screened, 292 (93 F, median age: 21years [range: 8-54]; 237 focal and 55 generalized epilepsy) fulfilled inclusion criteria. Median epilepsy duration was 11years. Levetiracetam had been introduced in 114 patients, VPA in 134, and OXC in 151 during the study period. Twenty-three were on LEV+OXC, 27 on LEV+VPA, and 33 on VPA+OXC. Behavioral disturbances (irritability, obsessive manifestations, aggressiveness, and frank psychosis) were observed in 43 patients; 23 on introduction of LEV (20.2%); LEV was discontinued in 10 (9%). Daytime somnolence was reported by 28 patients, 15 on OXC (10%); 8 received oral modafinil for the same, while none discontinued this AED. Only one patient on LEV and 3 on VPA reported EDS. Menstrual disturbances were reported by 9, weight gain by 3, and severe hair loss by 2 females on VPA.
Behavioral disturbances with levetiracetam are common among patients with refractory epilepsy while somnolence is common with oxcarbazepine. Antiepileptic drugs should be selected with this in perspective.
左乙拉西坦(LEV)常用于难治性癫痫的早期治疗;然而,其不良反应大多是在临床试验中进行研究的。奥卡西平和丙戊酸盐(VPA)是其他常用的抗癫痫药物(AEDs),因此可作为良好的对照。本研究旨在评估接受LEV和/或奥卡西平(OXC)治疗的癫痫患者与接受VPA治疗的患者相比的行为异常和嗜睡情况。
回顾了在2年半时间里连续就诊于我们难治性癫痫门诊的患者数据,纳入每月至少发作一次、开始使用LEV、VPA或OXC单药或联合用药的患者进行分析。除了收集与导致AED剂量减少或停药的任何主要影响相关的数据外,还收集了关于行为不良反应、日间嗜睡(EDS)和体重变化的数据。
在总共筛查的445例患者中,292例(93例女性,中位年龄:21岁[范围:8 - 54岁];237例局灶性癫痫和55例全身性癫痫)符合纳入标准。癫痫中位病程为11年。在研究期间,114例患者开始使用左乙拉西坦,134例使用VPA,151例使用OXC。23例使用LEV + OXC,27例使用LEV + VPA,33例使用VPA + OXC。43例患者出现行为障碍(易怒、强迫表现、攻击性和明显的精神病症状);23例在开始使用LEV时出现(20.2%);10例(9%)停用LEV。28例患者报告有日间嗜睡,15例在使用OXC时出现(10%);其中8例接受了口服莫达非尼治疗,无人停用该AED。仅1例使用LEV的患者和3例使用VPA的患者报告有EDS。9例患者报告有月经紊乱,3例体重增加,2例使用VPA的女性出现严重脱发。
左乙拉西坦引起的行为障碍在难治性癫痫患者中很常见,而嗜睡在奥卡西平治疗时很常见。选择抗癫痫药物时应考虑到这一点。