Calcagnile Olga, Anell Anders, Undén Johan
Department of Paediatric Medicine, Halmstad Regional Hospital, Halmstad, Sweden.
Barnkliniken, Hallandssjukhus Halmstad, 301 85, Halmstad, Sweden.
BMC Neurol. 2016 Oct 20;16(1):200. doi: 10.1186/s12883-016-0723-z.
Mild traumatic brain injury (TBI) is associated with substantial costs due to over-triage of patients to computed tomography (CT) scanning, despite validated decision rules. Serum biomarker S100B has shown promise for safely omitting CT scans but the economic impact from clinical use has never been reported. In 2007, S100B was adapted into the existing Scandinavian management guidelines in Halmstad, Sweden, in an attempt to reduce CT scans and save costs.
Consecutive adult patients with mild TBI (GCS 14-15, loss of consciousness and/or amnesia), managed with the aid of S100B, were prospectively included in this study. Patients were followed up after 3 months with a standardized questionnaire. Theoretical and actual cost differences were calculated.
Seven hundred twenty-six patients were included and 29 (4.7 %) showed traumatic abnormalities on CT. No further significant intracranial complications were discovered on follow-up. Two hundred twenty-nine patients (27 %) had normal S100B levels and 497 patients (73 %) showed elevated S100B levels. Over-triage occurred in 73 patients (32 %) and under-triage occurred in 39 patients (7 %). No significant intracranial complications were missed. The introduction of S100B could save 71 € per patient if guidelines were strictly followed. As compliance to the guidelines was not perfect, the actual cost saving was 39 € per patient.
Adding S100B to existing guidelines for mild TBI seems to reduce CT usage and costs, especially if guideline compliance could be increased.
尽管有经过验证的决策规则,但由于将患者过度分诊至计算机断层扫描(CT),轻度创伤性脑损伤(TBI)带来了巨大成本。血清生物标志物S100B已显示出安全省略CT扫描的前景,但临床应用的经济影响尚未见报道。2007年,S100B被纳入瑞典哈尔姆斯塔德现有的斯堪的纳维亚管理指南,以减少CT扫描并节省成本。
前瞻性纳入连续的成年轻度TBI患者(格拉斯哥昏迷量表评分14 - 15分,有意识丧失和/或失忆),这些患者在S100B的辅助下进行管理。3个月后用标准化问卷对患者进行随访。计算理论和实际成本差异。
纳入726例患者,29例(4.7%)CT显示有创伤性异常。随访中未发现进一步的严重颅内并发症。229例患者(27%)S100B水平正常,497例患者(73%)S'100B水平升高。73例患者(32%)出现过度分诊,39例患者(7%)出现分诊不足。未遗漏严重颅内并发症。如果严格遵循指南,引入S100B可使每位患者节省71欧元。由于对指南的依从性并非完美,实际每位患者节省成本39欧元。
在轻度TBI的现有指南中加入S100B似乎可减少CT使用和成本,特别是如果能提高指南依从性的话。