Hasegawa Kazuhiro, Kabata Tamon, Kajino Yoshitomo, Inoue Daisuke, Tsuchiya Hiroyuki
Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Graduate School of Medical Science, Kanazawa University, 13-1 Takaramachi, Kanazawa, Ishikawa, 920-8641, Japan.
Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2017 Feb;475(2):484-494. doi: 10.1007/s11999-016-5138-z. Epub 2016 Oct 31.
Periprosthetic fractures of the acetabulum occurring during primary THA are rare. Periprosthetic occult fractures are defined as those not identified by the surgeon during the procedure which might be missed on a routine postoperative radiograph. However, it is unclear how frequently these fractures occur and whether their presence affects functional recovery.
QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: In this study, using routine CT scans that were obtained as part of another primary hip arthroplasty study protocol, we retrospectively assessed (1) the prevalence of occult fractures of the acetabulum occurring during primary THA, (2) the location of occult fractures of the acetabulum during THA, and (3) risk factors contributing to such occult fractures.
Between 2004 and 2013, our institute performed 585 primary THAs (cementless or hybrid) in 494 patients with DICOM pre- and postoperative CT; during the period in question, all patients undergoing THA underwent CT before and after surgery. Preoperative CT images were taken as part of a CT-based three-dimensional templating software and navigation system. Postoperative CT images were taken an average of 1 week after surgery as part of a different protocol to evaluate cup position, restoration of leg length and offset, volume of postoperative hematoma to assess anticoagulation effects after THA, and fractures that were not found on routine postoperative radiographs (which we defined as occult fractures). Patients with a history of prior pelvic osteotomy, trauma, and infection were excluded (88 patients/99 hips); 406 patients (102 males and 304 females; 486 hips) form the basis of this report. The mean age of the patients was 60 ± 11 years, with a mean BMI of 23 ± 4 kg/m. The mean followup of the patients with periprosthetic fracture of the acetabulum was 58 ± 28 months (range, 12-131 months). Potential risk factors for occult acetabular fracture including age, sex, BMI, preoperative diagnosis, additional dome screw fixation, composition and size of each cup, and acetabular design were examined in multivariate analysis. Acetabular component designs were categorized as true hemispheric, peripheral self-locking, and elliptical; during the period in question the indications for each cup design were based on the brand of stem used. Comparison between preoperative and postoperative CT images was done to detect the fractures. Patients with fractures identified during surgery were treated with additional dome screw fixation and a 3-week period of nonweightbearing. Patients with occult fractures in this series did not receive additional treatment as we had confirmed secure fixation of the cup during surgery.
Occult fractures occurred in 41 hips (8.4%); periprosthetic fractures of the acetabulum were seen during surgery in an additional two hips (0.4%). The superolateral wall was the most frequent location for occult fractures of the acetabulum. After controlling for relevant confounding variables, only the use of peripheral self-locking cups was associated with an increased risk of occult fracture (odds ratio [OR], 2.6 compared with hemispheric cups; 95% CI, 1.2-5.6; p < 0.05). All patients with occult fractures showed bone ingrowth fixation at the final followup, without any additional surgical intervention.
Periprosthetic occult fractures of the acetabulum may occur relatively frequently during press-fit impaction. We observed a higher rate of fractures associated with the use of peripheral self-locking components. Occult acetabular fractures not detected on routine postoperative plain films may be ignored if secure fixation of the cup has been confirmed during the operation.
Level III, therapeutic study.
初次全髋关节置换术(THA)期间发生的髋臼假体周围骨折很罕见。假体周围隐匿性骨折定义为手术过程中未被外科医生识别且在术后常规X线片上可能漏诊的骨折。然而,目前尚不清楚这些骨折的发生频率以及它们的存在是否会影响功能恢复。
问题/目的:在本研究中,我们利用作为另一项初次髋关节置换术研究方案一部分而获得的常规CT扫描,回顾性评估了(1)初次THA期间髋臼隐匿性骨折的发生率,(2)THA期间髋臼隐匿性骨折的位置,以及(3)导致此类隐匿性骨折的危险因素。
2004年至2013年期间,我们的研究所对494例患者进行了585例初次THA(非骨水泥型或混合型),这些患者术前和术后均有DICOM格式的CT扫描;在该时间段内,所有接受THA的患者在手术前后均接受了CT检查。术前CT图像是基于CT的三维模板软件和导航系统的一部分进行拍摄的。术后CT图像在术后平均1周拍摄,作为不同方案的一部分,用于评估髋臼杯位置、肢体长度和偏心距的恢复情况、术后血肿体积以评估THA后的抗凝效果,以及术后常规X线片上未发现的骨折(我们将其定义为隐匿性骨折)。排除有骨盆截骨术、创伤和感染史的患者(88例患者/99髋);406例患者(102例男性和304例女性;486髋)构成了本报告的基础。患者的平均年龄为60±11岁,平均BMI为23±4kg/m²。髋臼假体周围骨折患者的平均随访时间为58±28个月(范围,12 - 131个月)。在多变量分析中检查了髋臼隐匿性骨折的潜在危险因素,包括年龄、性别、BMI、术前诊断、额外的髋臼顶螺钉固定、每个髋臼杯的组成和尺寸以及髋臼设计。髋臼假体设计分为真半球形、周边自锁形和椭圆形;在该时间段内,每种髋臼杯设计的适应证基于所使用的股骨柄品牌。通过比较术前和术后CT图像来检测骨折。术中发现骨折的患者接受了额外的髋臼顶螺钉固定和3周的不负重治疗。本系列中隐匿性骨折的患者未接受额外治疗,因为我们在手术中已确认髋臼杯固定牢固。
隐匿性骨折发生在41髋(8.4%);另外2髋(0.4%)在手术中发现髋臼假体周围骨折。髋臼上外侧壁是髋臼隐匿性骨折最常见的部位。在控制了相关混杂变量后,仅使用周边自锁型髋臼杯与隐匿性骨折风险增加相关(与半球形髋臼杯相比,优势比[OR]为2.6;95%CI,1.2 - 5.6;p < 0.05)。所有隐匿性骨折患者在最终随访时均显示骨长入固定,无需任何额外的手术干预。
压配植入过程中髋臼假体周围隐匿性骨折可能相对频繁发生。我们观察到使用周边自锁型部件相关的骨折发生率更高。如果在手术中已确认髋臼杯固定牢固,术后常规平片未检测到的髋臼隐匿性骨折可能可被忽略。
III级,治疗性研究。