Spafford C S
American International College, Springfield, MA 01109-3189.
Percept Mot Skills. 1989 Aug;69(1):115-25. doi: 10.2466/pms.1989.69.1.115.
The current study supports Levinson's contention (1988) that the diagnosis of dyslexia cannot be based solely on neurophysiological evidence but must be made in conjunction with reading and educational test scores. Contrary to much current research, in the present study specific WISC-R profiles are identified within a stringently defined subgroup of 57 9- to 12-yr-old dyslexic children. Well-defined subtest scatter can differentiate dyslexics from proficient readers. In particular, the Digit Span subtest, which is not routinely administered by psychologists or included in computing Verbal IQ, can be considered an important component of a diagnostic battery. Unexpectedly, Coding emerged with Digit Span as a third factor in a principal component analysis; statistically significant sex differences appeared on the Coding task. Findings appear to confirm the phonological encoding deficiencies displayed by dyslexics on the Digit Span subtest. This study strongly supports consideration of WISC-R subtest differences, along with correlated factors, neurophysiological and perceptual evidence, when diagnosing dyslexic children. Cross-validation is planned.
当前的研究支持莱文森(1988年)的观点,即诵读困难症的诊断不能仅仅基于神经生理学证据,而必须结合阅读和教育测试分数来做出。与当前的许多研究相反,在本研究中,在一个严格定义的由57名9至12岁诵读困难儿童组成的亚组中确定了特定的韦氏儿童智力量表修订版(WISC-R)剖面图。明确界定的分测验分数离散情况可以区分诵读困难儿童和熟练阅读者。特别是,数字广度分测验通常不由心理学家常规施测,也不包括在计算言语智商中,但可以被视为诊断组合的一个重要组成部分。出乎意料的是,在主成分分析中,译码与数字广度一起成为第三个因素;在译码任务上出现了具有统计学意义的性别差异。研究结果似乎证实了诵读困难儿童在数字广度分测验上表现出的语音编码缺陷。本研究强烈支持在诊断诵读困难儿童时考虑韦氏儿童智力量表修订版分测验差异,以及相关因素、神经生理学和感知证据。计划进行交叉验证。