Meulepas Johanna M, Ronckers Cécile M, Merks Johannes, Weijerman Michel E, Lubin Jay H, Hauptmann Michael
Department of Epidemiology and Biostatistics, Netherlands Cancer Institute, Amsterdam, The Netherlands.
J Radiol Prot. 2016 Dec;36(4):953-974. doi: 10.1088/0952-4746/36/4/953. Epub 2016 Nov 28.
Recent studies linking radiation exposure from pediatric computed tomography (CT) to increased risks of leukemia and brain tumors lacked data to control for cancer susceptibility syndromes (CSS). These syndromes might be confounders because they are associated with an increased cancer risk and may increase the likelihood of pediatric CT scans. We identify CSS predisposing to leukemia and brain tumors through a systematic literature search and summarize prevalence and risk. Since empirical evidence is lacking in published literature on patterns of CT use for most types of CSS, we estimate confounding bias of relative risks (RR) for categories of radiation exposure based on expert opinion about patterns of CT scans among CSS patients. We estimate that radiation-related RRs for leukemia are not meaningfully confounded by Down syndrome, Noonan syndrome and other CSS. Moreover, tuberous sclerosis complex, von Hippel-Lindau disease, neurofibromatosis type 1 and other CSS do not meaningfully confound RRs for brain tumors. Empirical data on the use of CT scans among CSS patients is urgently needed. Our assessment indicates that associations with radiation exposure from pediatric CT scans and leukemia or brain tumors reported in previous studies are unlikely to be substantially confounded by unmeasured CSS.
近期有关儿童计算机断层扫描(CT)辐射暴露与白血病和脑肿瘤风险增加相关的研究缺乏控制癌症易感性综合征(CSS)的数据。这些综合征可能是混杂因素,因为它们与癌症风险增加相关,并且可能增加儿童进行CT扫描的可能性。我们通过系统的文献检索确定易患白血病和脑肿瘤的CSS,并总结其患病率和风险。由于已发表文献中缺乏关于大多数类型CSS的CT使用模式的实证证据,我们基于专家对CSS患者CT扫描模式的意见,估计辐射暴露类别相对风险(RR)的混杂偏倚。我们估计,唐氏综合征、努南综合征和其他CSS不会对白血病的辐射相关RR产生有意义的混杂。此外,结节性硬化症复合体、冯·希佩尔-林道病、1型神经纤维瘤病和其他CSS不会对脑肿瘤的RR产生有意义的混杂。迫切需要关于CSS患者CT扫描使用情况的实证数据。我们的评估表明,先前研究中报告的儿童CT扫描辐射暴露与白血病或脑肿瘤之间的关联不太可能因未测量的CSS而受到实质性混杂。