Garofalo Sara, Timmermann Christopher, Battaglia Simone, Maier Martin E, di Pellegrino Giuseppe
University of Bologna.
University of Cambridge.
J Cogn Neurosci. 2017 Apr;29(4):718-727. doi: 10.1162/jocn_a_01074. Epub 2016 Nov 29.
The medial prefrontal cortex (mPFC) and ACC have been consistently implicated in learning predictions of future outcomes and signaling prediction errors (i.e., unexpected deviations from such predictions). A computational model of ACC/mPFC posits that these prediction errors should be modulated by outcomes occurring at unexpected times, even if the outcomes themselves are predicted. However, unexpectedness per se is not the only variable that modulates ACC/mPFC activity, as studies reported its sensitivity to the salience of outcomes. In this study, mediofrontal negativity, a component of the event-related brain potential generated in ACC/mPFC and coding for prediction errors, was measured in 48 participants performing a Pavlovian aversive conditioning task, during which aversive (thus salient) and neutral outcomes were unexpectedly shifted (i.e., anticipated or delayed) in time. Mediofrontal ERP signals of prediction error were observed for outcomes occurring at unexpected times but were specific for salient (shock-associated), as compared with neutral, outcomes. These findings have important implications for the theoretical accounts of ACC/mPFC and suggest a critical role of timing and salience information in prediction error signaling.
内侧前额叶皮质(mPFC)和前扣带回皮质(ACC)一直被认为与学习对未来结果的预测以及发出预测误差信号(即与此类预测的意外偏差)有关。ACC/mPFC的一个计算模型假定,即使结果本身是可预测的,这些预测误差也应该受到意外时间出现的结果的调节。然而,意外本身并不是调节ACC/mPFC活动的唯一变量,因为研究报告了其对结果显著性的敏感性。在本研究中,对48名执行巴甫洛夫厌恶条件反射任务的参与者测量了内侧前额叶负波,这是在ACC/mPFC中产生并编码预测误差的事件相关脑电位的一个成分,在此期间,厌恶(因此显著)和中性结果在时间上意外地发生了转移(即提前或延迟)。对于意外时间出现的结果观察到了预测误差的内侧前额叶ERP信号,但与中性结果相比,这些信号对显著(与电击相关)结果具有特异性。这些发现对ACC/mPFC的理论解释具有重要意义,并表明时间和显著性信息在预测误差信号传递中起着关键作用。