Orlando Francesca, Movedi Ermes, Coduto Davide, Parisi Simone, Brancadoro Lucio, Pagani Valentina, Guarneri Tommaso, Confalonieri Roberto
Department of Agricultural and Environmental Sciences-Production, Land, Agrienergy, Università degli Studi di Milano, via Celoria 2, I-20133 Milan, Italy.
Cassandra Lab, Università degli Studi di Milano, via Celoria 2, I-20133 Milan, Italy.
Sensors (Basel). 2016 Nov 26;16(12):2004. doi: 10.3390/s16122004.
Estimating leaf area index (LAI) of using indirect methods involves some critical issues, related to its discontinuous and non-homogeneous canopy. This study evaluates the smart app PocketLAI and hemispherical photography in vineyards against destructive LAI measurements. Data were collected during six surveys in an experimental site characterized by a high level of heterogeneity among plants, allowing us to explore a wide range of LAI values. During the last survey, the possibility to combine remote sensing data and in-situ PocketLAI estimates (smart scouting) was evaluated. Results showed a good agreement between PocketLAI data and direct measurements, especially for LAI ranging from 0.13 to 1.41 (² = 0.94, RRMSE = 17.27%), whereas the accuracy decreased when an outlying value (vineyard LAI = 2.84) was included (² = 0.77, RRMSE = 43.00%), due to the saturation effect in case of very dense canopies arising from lack of green pruning. The hemispherical photography showed very high values of ², even in presence of the outlying value (² = 0.94), although it showed a marked and quite constant overestimation error (RRMSE = 99.46%), suggesting the need to introduce a correction factor specific for vineyards. During the smart scouting, PocketLAI showed its reliability to monitor the spatial-temporal variability of vine vigor in cordon-trained systems, and showed a potential for a wide range of applications, also in combination with remote sensing.
使用间接方法估算叶面积指数(LAI)涉及一些关键问题,这些问题与冠层的不连续性和非均质性有关。本研究针对破坏性LAI测量,评估了葡萄园中的智能应用程序PocketLAI和半球摄影法。在一个植物间具有高度异质性的实验场地进行了六次调查,收集了相关数据,这使我们能够探究广泛的LAI值范围。在最后一次调查中,评估了结合遥感数据和现场PocketLAI估算值(智能监测)的可能性。结果表明,PocketLAI数据与直接测量值之间具有良好的一致性,尤其是对于LAI范围在0.13至1.41之间的情况(² = 0.94,相对均方根误差 = 17.27%),而当纳入一个异常值(葡萄园LAI = 2.84)时,准确性下降(² = 0.77,相对均方根误差 = 43.00%),这是由于缺乏绿色修剪导致冠层非常密集时出现的饱和效应。半球摄影法显示出非常高的²值,即使存在异常值时也是如此(² = 0.94),尽管它显示出明显且相当恒定的高估误差(相对均方根误差 = 99.46%),这表明需要引入特定于葡萄园的校正因子。在智能监测过程中,PocketLAI显示出其在监测单臂水平架式栽培系统中葡萄树活力时空变异性方面的可靠性,并显示出广泛的应用潜力,也可与遥感相结合。