Baek NamHuk, Seo Ok Won, Kim MinSung, Hulme John, An Seong Soo A
Department of R & D, NanoEntek Inc., Seoul, Republic of Korea.
Department of BioNano Technology Gachon University, Gyeonggi-do, Republic of Korea.
Onco Targets Ther. 2016 Nov 22;9:7207-7218. doi: 10.2147/OTT.S112566. eCollection 2016.
Recently, increasing numbers of cell culture experiments with 3D spheroids presented better correlating results in vivo than traditional 2D cell culture systems. 3D spheroids could offer a simple and highly reproducible model that would exhibit many characteristics of natural tissue, such as the production of extracellular matrix. In this paper numerous cell lines were screened and selected depending on their ability to form and maintain a spherical shape. The effects of increasing concentrations of doxorubicin (DXR) on the integrity and viability of the selected spheroids were then measured at regular intervals and in real-time. In total 12 cell lines, adenocarcinomic alveolar basal epithelial (A549), muscle (C2C12), prostate (DU145), testis (F9), pituitary epithelial-like (GH3), cervical cancer (HeLa), HeLa contaminant (HEp2), embryo (NIH3T3), embryo (PA317), neuroblastoma (SH-SY5Y), osteosarcoma U2OS, and embryonic kidney cells (293T), were screened. Out of the 12, 8 cell lines, NIH3T3, C2C12, 293T, SH-SY5Y, A549, HeLa, PA317, and U2OS formed regular spheroids and the effects of DXR on these structures were measured at regular intervals. Finally, 5 cell lines, A549, HeLa, SH-SY5Y, U2OS, and 293T, were selected for real-time monitoring and the effects of DXR treatment on their behavior were continuously recorded for 5 days. A potential correlation regarding the effects of DXR on spheroid viability and ATP production was measured on days 1, 3, and 5. Cytotoxicity of DXR seemed to occur after endocytosis, since the cellular activities and ATP productions were still viable after 1 day of the treatment in all spheroids, except SH-SY5Y. Both cellular activity and ATP production were halted 3 and 5 days from the start of the treatment in all spheroids. All cell lines maintained their spheroid shape, except SHSY-5, which behaved in an unpredictable manner when exposed to toxic concentrations of DXR. Cytotoxic effects of DXR towards SH-SY5Y seemed to cause degradation of the extracellular matrix, since all cells were dismantled from the spheroid upon cell death. On the other hand, 293T spheroids revealed retarded cellular activity and ATP productions upon DXR treatment throughout the experiment. Since 293T was the embryonic kidney cells, the fast clearance or neutralizations could have made them resistant towards DXR. In conclusion, the same degree of sensitivity from the 2D system did not translate to a 3D culture system, resulting in higher IC50 values than the 2D system. The varying sensitivities and tolerances to drugs could be better understood with a 3D cell culture system.
最近,越来越多使用3D球体的细胞培养实验在体内呈现出比传统2D细胞培养系统更好的相关结果。3D球体可以提供一个简单且高度可重复的模型,该模型将展现天然组织的许多特性,如细胞外基质的产生。在本文中,根据众多细胞系形成和维持球形的能力进行了筛选和选择。然后定期并实时测量阿霉素(DXR)浓度增加对所选球体完整性和活力的影响。总共筛选了12种细胞系,分别为腺癌肺泡基底上皮细胞(A549)、肌肉细胞(C2C12)、前列腺细胞(DU145)、睾丸细胞(F9)、垂体上皮样细胞(GH3)、子宫颈癌细胞(HeLa)、HeLa污染细胞(HEp2)、胚胎细胞(NIH3T3)、胚胎细胞(PA317)、神经母细胞瘤细胞(SH-SY5Y)、骨肉瘤U2OS细胞以及胚胎肾细胞(293T)。在这12种细胞系中,8种细胞系,即NIH3T3、C2C12、293T、SH-SY5Y、A549、HeLa、PA317和U2OS形成了规则的球体,并定期测量DXR对这些结构的影响。最后,选择了5种细胞系,即A549、HeLa、SH-SY5Y、U2OS和293T进行实时监测,并连续5天记录DXR处理对其行为的影响。在第1天、第3天和第5天测量了DXR对球体活力和ATP产生影响的潜在相关性。DXR的细胞毒性似乎在胞吞作用后发生,因为在处理1天后,除SH-SY5Y外,所有球体中的细胞活性和ATP产生仍然存活。从处理开始3天和5天后,所有球体中的细胞活性和ATP产生均停止。除SHSY-5外,所有细胞系均保持其球体形状,SHSY-5在暴露于有毒浓度的DXR时表现出不可预测的行为。DXR对SH-SY5Y的细胞毒性似乎导致细胞外基质降解,因为所有细胞在细胞死亡时都从球体中解体。另一方面,在整个实验过程中,293T球体在DXR处理后显示出细胞活性和ATP产生延迟。由于293T是胚胎肾细胞,快速清除或中和可能使它们对DXR具有抗性。总之,2D系统的相同敏感性程度在3D培养系统中并未体现,导致IC50值高于2D系统。使用3D细胞培养系统可以更好地理解对药物的不同敏感性和耐受性。