Dressler Corinna, Rosumeck Stefanie, Sunderkötter Cord, Werner Ricardo Niklas, Nast Alexander
Division of Evidence-Based Medicine (dEBM), Department of Dermatology, Venereology and Allergology, Charité - Universitätsmedizin Berlin; Department of Dermatology and Venereology, University Hospital Halle.
Dtsch Arztebl Int. 2016 Nov 14;113(45):757-762. doi: 10.3238/arztebl.2016.0757.
Scabies is a contagious infestation transmitted by skin-to-skin contact and sometimes by contact with contaminated material. The scabies mite burrows into the skin, producing a papular rash and severe itch at typical sites of predilection.
We systematically reviewed the literature to compare the efficacy of various anti-scabies agents, including a calculation of relative risks and confidence intervals.
A literature search yielded 596 initial hits; after screening in accor-dance with the defined inclusion and exclusion criteria, 16 studies were selected for this review. Among topical treatments for scabies, permethrin was equally effective or more effective than crotamiton or benzyl benzoate. In a comparison of topical versus systemic treatment, topical permethrin and systemic ivermectin did not differ substantially in efficacy (7 comparative studies revealed no difference; one revealed a difference in favor of permethrin). Comparative trials of topical benzyl benzoate versus systemic ivermectin yielded inconsistent findings. Single and double administrations of ivermectin were similarly effective. In trials involving entire populations with a high prevalence of scabies, systemic ivermectin was found to be superior to topical permethrin.
There are hardly any differences in efficacy between the available treatments for scabies. Single administrations of permethrin 5%, crotamiton 10%, and systemic ivermectin are all comparably effective. There are differences in the frequeny and ease of application as well as when eradicating scabies in populations with a high prevalence.
疥疮是一种通过皮肤接触传播的传染性寄生虫病,有时也可通过接触受污染的物品传播。疥螨会钻入皮肤,在典型的好发部位产生丘疹性皮疹并伴有剧烈瘙痒。
我们系统回顾了文献,以比较各种抗疥疮药物的疗效,包括计算相对风险和置信区间。
文献检索初步得到596条结果;按照既定的纳入和排除标准进行筛选后,选取了16项研究进行本综述。在疥疮的局部治疗中,氯菊酯与克罗米通或苯甲酸苄酯相比,疗效相当或更优。在局部治疗与全身治疗的比较中,局部用氯菊酯和全身用伊维菌素在疗效上没有显著差异(7项比较研究显示无差异;1项显示氯菊酯更具优势)。局部用苯甲酸苄酯与全身用伊维菌素的比较试验结果不一致。单次和两次服用伊维菌素的效果相似。在疥疮高流行率的整个人群试验中,发现全身用伊维菌素优于局部用氯菊酯。
现有的疥疮治疗方法在疗效上几乎没有差异。单次使用5%氯菊酯、10%克罗米通和全身用伊维菌素的效果相当。在应用频率和难易程度以及在高流行率人群中根除疥疮方面存在差异。