Saraf Suma Prahlad, Saraf Prahlad Annappa, Kamatagi Laxmikant, Hugar Santosh, Tamgond Shridevi, Patil Jayakumar
Department of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery, PMNM Dental College and Hospital, Bagalkot, Karnataka, India.
Department of Conservative Dentistry and Endodontics, PMNM Dental College and Hospital, Bagalkot, Karnataka, India.
J Conserv Dent. 2016 Nov-Dec;19(6):527-531. doi: 10.4103/0972-0707.194021.
The ideal maxillary injection should produce a rapid onset of profound pulpal anesthesia for multiple teeth from a single needle penetration. The main objective is to compare the efficacy of articaine 4% and lidocaine 2% and to compare anterior middle superior alveolar nerve block (AMSANB) and infraorbital nerve block (IONB) for anesthesia of maxillary teeth.
Forty patients undergoing root canal treatment of maxillary anteriors and premolars were included and randomly divided into four groups of ten each. Group I: patients receiving AMSANB with articaine, Group II: Patients receiving IONB with articaine, Group III: Patients receiving AMSANB with lidocaine, Group IV: Patients receiving IONB with lidocaine. The scores of onset of anesthesia and pain perception were statistically analyzed.
Onset of action was fastest for articaine with AMSANB and slowest for lidocaine with IONB by Tukey's test. A significant change was observed in the electrical pulp test readings at onset and at 30 min by paired -test. All patients experienced mild pain during the procedure recorded by visual analog scale.
Articaine 4% proved to be more efficacious than lidocaine 2%, and AMSANB was more advantageous than IONB in securing anesthesia of maxillary anteriors and premolars.
理想的上颌注射应通过单次进针实现对多颗牙齿快速产生深度牙髓麻醉。主要目的是比较4%阿替卡因和2%利多卡因的疗效,并比较前中牙槽神经阻滞(AMSANB)和眶下神经阻滞(IONB)在上颌牙齿麻醉中的效果。
纳入40例接受上颌前牙和前磨牙根管治疗的患者,随机分为四组,每组10例。第一组:接受阿替卡因AMSANB的患者;第二组:接受阿替卡因IONB的患者;第三组:接受利多卡因AMSANB的患者;第四组:接受利多卡因IONB的患者。对麻醉起效和疼痛感知评分进行统计学分析。
通过Tukey检验,阿替卡因联合AMSANB起效最快,利多卡因联合IONB起效最慢。通过配对检验,在麻醉开始时和30分钟时牙髓电测试读数有显著变化。所有患者在手术过程中通过视觉模拟量表记录均经历轻度疼痛。
4%阿替卡因比2%利多卡因更有效,在确保上颌前牙和前磨牙麻醉方面,AMSANB比IONB更具优势。