Saratzis A, Calderbank T, Sidloff D, Bown M J, Davies R S
Department of Cardiovascular Sciences and Leicester NIHR Cardiovascular Biomedical Research Unit, University of Leicester, Leicester, UK.
Department of Medical and Social Care Education, University of Leicester, Leicester, UK.
Eur J Vasc Endovasc Surg. 2017 Feb;53(2):193-198. doi: 10.1016/j.ejvs.2016.11.016. Epub 2016 Dec 18.
Endovascular aneurysm repair (EVAR) requires a high-level of technical-competency to avoid device-related complications. Virtual reality simulation-based training (SBT) may offer an alternative method of psychomotor skill acquisition; however, its role in EVAR training is undefined. This study aimed to: a) benchmark competency levels using EVAR SBT, and b) investigate the impact of supervised SBT on trainee performance.
EVAR procedure-related metrics were benchmarked by six experienced consultants using a Simbionix Angiomentor EVAR simulator. Sixteen vascular surgical trainees performing a comparable EVAR before and after structured SBT (>4 teaching sessions) were assessed utilising a modified Likert-scale score. These were benchmarked for comparison against the standard set by the consultant body.
Median procedural-time for consultants was 43.5 min (IQR 7.5). A significant improvement in trainee procedural-time following SBT was observed (median procedural time 77 min [IQR 20.75] vs. 56 min [IQR: 7.00], p < .0001). The mean (SD) trainee Likert score pre- and post-SBT improved (16.6 [SD 1.455] vs. 28.63 [SD 2.986], p < .0001). Fewer endoleaks were observed (p = .0063) and trainees chose an appropriately sized device more often after SBT.
This study suggests that EVAR-SBT should be considered as an adjunct to standard psychomotor skill teaching techniques for EVAR within the vascular surgery training curricula.
血管内动脉瘤修复术(EVAR)需要高水平的技术能力以避免与器械相关的并发症。基于虚拟现实模拟的培训(SBT)可能提供一种获取心理运动技能的替代方法;然而,其在EVAR培训中的作用尚不明确。本研究旨在:a)使用EVAR SBT对能力水平进行基准测试,以及b)研究有监督的SBT对学员表现的影响。
由六名经验丰富的顾问使用Simbionix Angiomentor EVAR模拟器对与EVAR手术相关的指标进行基准测试。对16名血管外科实习生在结构化SBT(>4次教学课程)前后进行类似的EVAR操作进行评估,采用改良的李克特量表评分。将这些评分与顾问团队设定的标准进行比较以作基准。
顾问的中位手术时间为43.5分钟(四分位间距7.5)。观察到SBT后学员的手术时间有显著改善(中位手术时间77分钟[四分位间距20.75]对56分钟[四分位间距:7.00],p<.0001)。学员SBT前后的平均(标准差)李克特评分有所提高(16.6[标准差1.455]对28.63[标准差2.986],p<.0001)。观察到内漏减少(p=.0063),并且学员在SBT后更常选择尺寸合适的器械。
本研究表明,在血管外科培训课程中,EVAR-SBT应被视为EVAR标准心理运动技能教学技术的辅助手段。