Institute for Advanced Sustainability Studies e.V., Berliner Strasse 130, D-14467 Potsdam.
Sci Total Environ. 2017 Feb 15;580:90-104. doi: 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2016.07.200. Epub 2016 Dec 21.
Since solar radiation management (SRM) technologies do not yet exist and capacities to model their impacts are limited, proposals for its governance are implicitly designed not around realities, but possibilities - baskets of risk and benefit that are often components of future imaginaries. This paper reports on the project Solar Radiation Management: Foresight for Governance (SRM4G), which aimed to encourage an anticipatory mode of thinking about the future of an engineered climate. Leveraging the participation of 15 scholars and practitioners heavily engaged in early conversations on SRM governance, SRM4G applied scenario construction to generate a set of alternative futures leading to 2030, each exercising different influences on the need for - and challenges associated with - development of SRM technologies. The scenarios then provided the context for the design of systems of governance with the capacity and legitimacy to respond to those challenges, and for the evaluation of the advantages and drawbacks of different options against a wide range of imaginary but plausible futures. SRM4G sought to initiate a conversation within the SRM research community on the capacity of foresight approaches to highlight the centrality of conceptions of the future to discussions of SRM's threats and opportunities, and in doing so, examined and challenged the assumptions embedded in conceptualizing SRM's aims, development and governance, and discussed the capacity of governance options to adapt to a wide range of possibilities.
由于太阳辐射管理 (SRM) 技术尚不存在,且建模其影响的能力有限,因此其治理的提案并非基于现实,而是基于可能性——风险和利益的篮子,这些往往是未来想象的组成部分。本文报告了太阳辐射管理:治理展望 (SRM4G) 项目,该项目旨在鼓励对工程气候未来进行前瞻性思考。利用 15 名学者和从业人员的参与,他们深入参与了早期关于 SRM 治理的对话,SRM4G 应用情景构建来生成一组通向 2030 年的替代未来情景,这些情景对 SRM 技术的需求和发展带来了不同的影响。然后,这些情景为设计具有应对这些挑战的能力和合法性的治理系统提供了背景,并对不同选择在广泛的想象但合理的未来中的优势和劣势进行了评估。SRM4G 试图在 SRM 研究界内发起一场关于前瞻性方法的能力的对话,以突出对未来的构想对 SRM 的威胁和机遇讨论的核心地位,同时,审视和挑战了在构想 SRM 的目标、发展和治理时所嵌入的假设,并讨论了治理选择适应广泛可能性的能力。