Nation Javan, Jiang Wen
Rady Children's Hospital San Diego Pediatric Otolaryngology, 3030 Children's Way Suite 402, San Diego, CA 92123, USA; University of California San Diego, Division of Otolaryngology, 200 West Arbor Drive, San Diego, CA 92103, USA.
Int J Pediatr Otorhinolaryngol. 2017 Jan;92:1-6. doi: 10.1016/j.ijporl.2016.10.035. Epub 2016 Nov 1.
To test the ability of a handheld metal detector (HHMD) to identify the presence and location of ingested metallic foreign bodies (MFBs) in children.
Prospective case series enrolling children suspected of metallic foreign body ingestion presenting to the Emergency Department. Thirty-eight children were enrolled and the HHMD was used to detect the presence and location of a MFB. Results were compared to standard radiographic studies.
Thirty-seven of the 38 ingested foreign bodies were MFBs. Of the 37 MFBs, the HHMD positively identified 33, and 4 were missed by HHMD but identified on radiography. When positive, the location indicated by HHMD correlated 100% with radiograph. There were 33 true positives, 0 false positives, 4 false negatives, and 1 true negative. This resulted in a sensitivity of 89% (95% CI of 75%-96%) and specificity of 100% (95% CI of 2.5%-100%).
Our study demonstrates the accuracy of HHMD in the identification and localization of metallic foreign bodies. We propose an emergency room foreign body protocol that uses HHMD as an early screening tool in triage in order to expedite the process of obtaining Otolaryngology consultation and potentially shorten the wait time to the operating room or discharge. In instances were outside films are previously performed, HHMD use may be able to minimize the overall radiation exposure to children by obviating the need for repeat radiographs. As the sensitivity is not 100%, a negative HHMD screening does not negate the need for a standard radiograph in order to avoid missed MFBs. HHMD is best suited for detection of coins, which accounts for the majority of the MFB ingestions, and may not be suitable for all metallic objects since the amount of metal may decrease its sensitivity.
测试手持式金属探测器(HHMD)识别儿童摄入金属异物(MFB)的存在及位置的能力。
前瞻性病例系列研究,纳入到急诊科就诊的疑似摄入金属异物的儿童。共纳入38名儿童,使用HHMD检测MFB的存在及位置。将结果与标准放射学检查进行比较。
38例摄入的异物中有37例为MFB。在这37例MFB中,HHMD正确识别出33例,4例被HHMD漏诊但在放射学检查中被发现。当检测结果为阳性时,HHMD指示的位置与放射影像的结果100%相符。有33例假阳性、0例假阴性、4例假阴性和1例真阴性。这使得灵敏度为89%(95%置信区间为75%-96%),特异度为100%(95%置信区间为2.5%-100%)。
我们的研究证明了HHMD在识别和定位金属异物方面的准确性。我们提出一种急诊室异物处理方案,在分诊时将HHMD用作早期筛查工具,以加快获得耳鼻喉科会诊的流程,并可能缩短等待手术室治疗或出院的时间。在之前已进行过外部X光检查的情况下,使用HHMD可能能够避免重复进行X光检查,从而将儿童的总体辐射暴露降至最低。由于灵敏度并非100%,HHMD筛查结果为阴性并不能排除进行标准X光检查的必要性,以避免漏诊MFB。HHMD最适合检测硬币,硬币占大多数MFB摄入病例,并且可能不适用于所有金属物体,因为金属量可能会降低其灵敏度。