Christenson Elizabeth C, Serre Marc L
Department of Environmental Sciences & Engineering, Gillings School of Global Public Health, The University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, NC, USA.
Department of Environmental Sciences & Engineering, Gillings School of Global Public Health, The University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, NC, USA.
Sci Total Environ. 2017 Feb 15;580:865-872. doi: 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2016.12.033. Epub 2016 Dec 22.
North Carolina (NC) regulates swine concentrated animal feeding operations (CAFOs) using five-year nutrient management plans (NMPs) requiring the plant available nitrogen sprayed (PANspray) to be less than that utilized by crops (PANcrops), i.e. the PAN balance (defined as PANbal=PANspray-PANcrops) remains negative, which avoids over-spraying liquid effluent onto crops. Objectives of this research are first to characterize Duplin County sprayfields and PANbal by creating the first, open-source sprayfield spatial database created for swine CAFOs in NC (for Duplin County). Second, this paper finds that for two sub-watershed scales 199 additional catchments and 1 additional HUC12 were identified as having permitted lagoon effluent applied compared to using CAFO point locations for a total of 510 catchments and 34 HUC12s with swine CAFO sprayfields. Third, a new method disaggregates annual PANbal from NMPs using remote sensing crop data. And finally, probability that sprayfields have excess PANbal is estimated due to k, a PAN availability coefficient. The remote sensing approach finds that 9-14% of catchments in a given year and 24% of catchments over a five year period have a positive PANbal. An additional 3-4% of catchments have probability of a positive PANbal due to variability in k. This work quantifies the impact of crop rotations on of sprayfields at the catchment spatial scale with respect to PANbal and highlights some of the limitations of NMPs have for estimation of PANbal. We recommend that NMPs be permitted based on the crop rotation scenario utilizing the least PAN and that swine producer compliance to manure management practice be encouraged.
北卡罗来纳州(NC)通过五年养分管理计划(NMPs)对猪集中式动物饲养场(CAFOs)进行监管,该计划要求喷洒的植物有效氮(PANspray)低于作物利用的量(PANcrops),即PAN平衡(定义为PANbal = PANspray - PANcrops)保持为负,这可避免向作物过度喷洒液体废水。本研究的目标首先是通过创建北卡罗来纳州(针对达普林县)首个用于猪CAFOs的开源喷洒场空间数据库,来表征达普林县的喷洒场和PAN平衡。其次,本文发现,与使用CAFO点位置相比,在两个子流域尺度上,又识别出199个额外的集水区和1个额外的水文单元代码12(HUC12)有允许施用的泻湖废水,猪CAFO喷洒场涉及的集水区总数达到510个,HUC12达到34个。第三,一种新方法利用遥感作物数据对NMPs中的年度PAN平衡进行分解。最后,由于PAN有效性系数k,估计了喷洒场PAN平衡超标的概率。遥感方法发现,在给定年份中,9 - 14%的集水区以及在五年期间24%的集水区有正的PAN平衡。另外3 - 4%的集水区由于k的变异性有正PAN平衡的概率。这项工作在集水区空间尺度上量化了作物轮作对喷洒场PAN平衡的影响,并突出了NMPs在估计PAN平衡方面的一些局限性。我们建议根据使用最少PAN的作物轮作方案来批准NMPs,并鼓励养猪生产者遵守粪便管理实践。