McDowell J J
Emory University.
Behav Anal. 2013 Fall;36(2):345-359. doi: 10.1007/BF03392319.
In science we study processes in the material world. The way these processes operate can be discovered by conducting experiments that activate them, and findings from such experiments can lead to functional complexity theories of how the material processes work. The results of a good functional theory will agree with experimental measurements, but the theory may not incorporate in its algorithmic workings a representation of the material processes themselves. Nevertheless, the algorithmic operation of a good functional theory may be said to make contact with material reality by incorporating the emergent computations the material processes carry out. These points are illustrated in the experimental analysis of behavior by considering an evolutionary theory of behavior dynamics, the algorithmic operation of which does not correspond to material features of the physical world, but the functional output of which agrees quantitatively and qualitatively with findings from a large body of research with live organisms.
在科学领域,我们研究物质世界中的过程。这些过程的运作方式可以通过进行激活它们的实验来发现,此类实验的结果能够引出关于物质过程如何运作的功能复杂性理论。一个良好的功能理论的结果将与实验测量结果相符,但该理论在其算法运作中可能并未纳入物质过程本身的表征。然而,可以说一个良好的功能理论的算法运作通过纳入物质过程所执行的涌现计算与物质现实产生了联系。通过考虑行为动力学的进化理论,这些观点在行为的实验分析中得到了说明,该理论的算法运作与物理世界的物质特征并不对应,但其功能输出在定量和定性方面都与大量关于活体生物的研究结果相符。