Shimp Charles P
University of Utah.
Behav Anal. 2013 Fall;36(2):295-312. doi: 10.1007/BF03392316.
Three categories of behavior analysis may be called and Molecular analyses focus on how manual shaping segments moment-to-moment behaving into new, unified, hierarchically organized patterns. Manual shaping is largely atheoretical, qualitative, and practical. Molar analyses aggregate behaviors and then compute a numerical average for the aggregate. Typical molar analyses involve average rate of, or average time allocated to, the aggregated behaviors. Some molar analyses have no known relation to any behavior stream. Molar analyses are usually quantitative and often theoretical. Unified analyses combine automated shaping of moment-to-moment behaving and molar aggregates of the shaped patterns. Unified controlling relations suggest that molar controlling relations like matching confound shaping and strengthening effects of reinforcement. If a molecular analysis is about how reinforcement organizes individual behavior moment by moment, and a molar analysis is about how reinforcement encourages more or less of an activity aggregated over time, then a unified analysis handles both kinds of analyses. Only theories engendered by computer simulation appear to be able to unify all three categories of behavior analysis.
行为分析可分为三类,即分子分析、整体分析和统一分析。分子分析关注的是如何通过手动塑造将瞬间行为片段整合成新的、统一的、层次组织化的模式。手动塑造在很大程度上是无理论的、定性的和实践性的。整体分析将行为汇总,然后计算汇总行为的数值平均值。典型的整体分析涉及汇总行为的平均速率或分配给汇总行为的平均时间。一些整体分析与任何行为流都没有已知的关系。整体分析通常是定量的,而且常常是理论性的。统一分析将瞬间行为的自动塑造与塑造模式的整体汇总结合起来。统一控制关系表明,像匹配这样的整体控制关系混淆了强化的塑造和强化效果。如果分子分析是关于强化如何逐 moment 组织个体行为,而整体分析是关于强化如何鼓励随着时间推移汇总的某种活动或多或少,那么统一分析则处理这两种分析。似乎只有计算机模拟产生的理论能够统一行为分析的所有三类。